revnice1
Anderton:
I've always thought of normalization as the cardinal sin because of what it does to the dynamics but I'll take your word for it and give it a try. Why phrase by phrase?
Because it maintains the internal dynamics of the phrase. Think about it for a second...people compress the living daylights out of vocals, which destroys dynamic range FAR more than just making sure that the peaks of phrases are consistent. Normalization doesn't destroy dynamics; whatever dynamics were there in the first place, remain.
Of course, this isn't an automatic process...that's why it takes so long to do it right. There will be times when normalization brings up quiet parts that were
supposed to be quiet, and you don't want to do that.
The bottom line is for me, normalization makes vocals "pop," and yet include dynamics, in a way that compression can't. If you listen to my album
Simplicity, you'll hear that almost all the vocals are not just individual vocals, but you'll also hear how the normalization brings them up front in the mix, without a lot of compression.