Thank you everyone for your comments on the recording and the mix, as well as the band. The band is pretty tight. The lead guitarist really stays true to the act, for sure.
My recording process/signal chain consisted of:
Male vocal: Rode NT-1000
Female vocal: AT-2020
Lead guitar: Royer R-101 ribbon in front of a vintage Fender Twin
Rhythm acoustic guitar: Direct via GT-8 Guitar FX Processor
Bass guitar: Direct In
Kick: Beta 52-a
Snare: Two SM-57's (one above, one underneath)
Toms and cymbals: Two overhead PG-81's
Thanks again everyone for your ears!