Terrible news about the demise of Sonar. I feel sorry for those of you that have supported it all these years.
I don't do nearly as much recording as I used to but, AFA Sam goes, I've been using it for several years so here are a few thoughts.
I bought the inexpensive Magix Music Studio (sortof a Samplitude lite) years ago to use as a replacement for Cooledit (which Adobe wanted an arm and a leg to upgrade to Audition). I liked it so much that I bought Sam9. I personally don't think I have any use for SoundForge because Sam handles my audio needs well enough. I don't understand why Magix bought it.
Things I like about Sam vs Sonar:
* comparisonics wav display. Displays the wavform in color, with higher frequencies brighter colors. Makes it easier to zoom in on a particular part for editing. Here's a Kraznet video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=go7a09fsI7c * Opening/importing a wav file is much faster than Sonar. After a file is opened, auxiliary meta files are written to the same folder that make reopening/displaying the file again practically instantaneous. Even if Sam had never opened the wav file before, it's still very fast compared to Sonar.
* You can do several non-destructive edits on wav files. Then, you can just freeze/unfreeze the track or object. If I remember correctly, in Sonar pretty much everything to do with wav files was destructive.
* Many great sounding high quality plugins are included.
* It seems like things sound better in Sam. I know it's probably just psychological, but so what? It seems to sound clearer so I think that's a plus.
Things I don't like as much as Sonar:
* Comping feels more intuitive in Sonar. (My favorite comping was Project 5's)
* Liquid Mix never worked right in Sam but worked perfectly in Sonar. It stuttered horribly in Sam. That's irrelevant now that firewire is gone.
* The midi implementation is not as versatile as it is in Sonar. But it's pretty darn good though. I put in a feature request to use a scripting language like Python to manipulate midi files but nothing's come of it yet. CAL is bizarre but at least it's something..
* Sam's documentation is pretty poor. Lots of german-to-english translation mistakes, and some things are not described in depth. The forum and Kraznet's videos are invaluable.