Reaper was mentioned on that forum many times, I mean before CW crash.
I guess negativity and ignorance about Reaper inducted by:
1) "it is AWESOME! I *LOVE* it etc.". Because of ads we all see everywhere, every day, on TV and Internet, most people reaction on that is opposite from the intention: "I don't f... care what you love!!!", "yet another ad/funboy". I mean people tend to run away quick from everything with such promotions.
I do not like it, and the fact you had to create the second account is a prove I am not alone.
2) 2-3 people developed DAW can not be serious.
Normally, it is not know how many people create a product. And the information what else is used is rarely public. That way that product can be sold as "solid".
Small projects (f.e. a VST) in many cases can be and are developed just by one programmer.
If you let me guess how many programmers was working on Sonar core engine last years, i will say - less (!) then one (!). One full time programmer could produce quite significant changes. What else except ARA, some cosmetic interface improvements and bug fixes was done? Apart from any plug-ins, CCC and other not engine components?
3) "they do no play fair concurrence" ... that argument was continuously mentioned by some respectable people.
I think that is completely irrelevant. "Moral" in choosing the DAW? We know that the world is not fair. We can not change that. That is not a reason to use bad software. There are many fonds where money can be sent to make us think "we help poor people...".
4) $60 DAW is always a toy. No "pro" are using it.
If someone is a "pro", he/she knows what he/she wants to use and why. If someone is not a "pro", "pro" DAW/guitar/mic/hammer unlikely is going to change that status.
Reaper is $225. And that is only(!) to the DAW. No loops, no 3d party plug-ins. Remove the price of all plug-ins and content from any "big player" bundle, how much from the bundle price is really the DAW price?
$60 is permanent discount. "Cubase and Studio One have super price for us now!". Waves have "sales" every days (down to 90% off!). That gives people impression they get something "big" for "little". Well, then think the same way about $60 for Reaper.