Reminds me of "Cakewalk will be gone within a year now that it's been acquired by Gibson," "Cakewalk will never be able to deliver monthly updates," "Cakewalk can't survive offering limited time Lifetime Updates," "Analytics will steal my music," etc.
Any change is met with resistance. CW fine-tunes things over time, stuff ends up working, and then everyone has collective amnesia about saying things would never work. Goes with the territory, I suppose.
I'm not arguing with anyone, just pointing out precedent. It's crazy to judge something that hasn't been in operation for even 24 hours, especially when the success of the concept itself depends on development
over time. Have an open mind, give it a shot, and see what happens.