I may be judging this completely wrong but I'm wondering if the OP actually needs a "mixer". While it is true many people like moving faders by hand rather than with a mouse, for many studios it is not a requirement at all these days. You need a set of good quality inputs and outputs (and even then only as many as you plan to be using simultaneously during recording or monitoring) but most of the time all "mixing" is done in the computer, with or without a controller.
So to the OP, sorry if I'm misjudging your level of experience but if you are expecting that you need to use a 32 channel mixer to mix 32 channels in Sonar, you don't. If, for example, you're only going to be recording vocals, guitars and the odd keyboard, you only really need two high quality inputs. In such a case you'd be far better of with, say, an RME BabyFace than with a giant Behringer X32 (even though I do like it, just for a different purpose). That would get you high quality recordings and leave you to figure out exactly what kind of controller you'd like. E.g., Cakewalk is working on Softube Console One integration. Which is more of a per-channel EQ/Compression controller than a multi fader approach but if you're looking for that "analog feel" it might suit you better.