Musikman
Max Output Level: -86 dBFS
- Total Posts : 220
- Joined: 2008/08/26 11:21:27
- Location: NorthEast, USA
- Status: offline
New Laptop and HD speed question
Hi all, long time I haven't been here, hope everyone is doing well! First question....I'm finally shopping around to move out of this dinosaur single core PC I've been using for years, and into a new laptop. Couple questions....I know from years of running Cakewalk that a 7200RPM HD is the best way to go, however, the laptop I'm looking at purchasing only comes with a 5400RPM HD, as it seems most all of them do. My computer repair friend who is also a recording musician recommended one possibility instead of having the store replace the HD with a faster one before I buy it, that I may as well just get a 7200RPM External HD, seeing as how I'd have to buy a HD anyhow. That way I can run Sonar on the main C drive and run my project files off the external. Now I know that is possible having done it before, and it would work, I'm just trying to find out if there are any downfalls and/or advantages associated with using two different hard drives to record with. I believe the USB is 3.0 on the new laptop. Here is the model I'm looking at possibly buying.....comes with Windows 8 http://www.bestbuy.com/site/15-6-touch-screen-laptop-8gb-memory-1tb-hard-drive/8937158.p?id=1218954926513&skuId=8937158&st=%20Asus%2015.6 I've learned a lot over the years about PC's but I'm certainly no expert, I'd rather just record music and not have to think too deep about anything else PC related. So if anyone could possibly let me know if that ASUS model laptop is a good choice, I would appreciate your input on this. Second question....I've never owned a laptop, so I'm assuming I won't be able to use my M-Audio Delta - 66 sound card and will have to get some kind of USB audio interface, any suggestions on a decent one of those that is not too pricey and has the same amount of inputs/outputs as my Delta66 would be a big help as well. Thanks very much! MM
post edited by Musikman - 2013/10/16 10:15:59
Sonar Platinum, Win10 Pro 64bit, AMD FX 6300 6 Core, 8GB RAM, AMD Radeon R9-380
|
spacealf
Max Output Level: -54 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2133
- Joined: 2010/11/18 17:44:34
- Status: offline
Re: New Laptop and HD speed question
2013/10/16 16:11:39
(permalink)
Well, as to the computer I think this is not needed and will have to be turned off (down next paragraph). Along with Wi-fi when not using it if you do use it. You have a cable connection for the Internet also, wi-fi interferes with recording audio. (I took wi-fi connection out of my new computer - don't use it). "Built-in HD webcam with microphoneMakes it easy to video chat with family and friends or teleconference with colleagues over Skype or other popular applications." (probably turn off when recording like wi-fi in Device Manager). I assume it is a 6Gb/sec Sata transfer for the harddisk although I have not found that yet. Asus is usually pretty good except my old desktop is over 6 years old but it worked fine in XP OS. That speed is probably the standard but I see no speed mentioned on that link you provided. Safe to assume that is the speed. Only having a 5400 RPM drive is a problem since there are only 3 USB ports in the computer. An audio interface USB takes up one port and a lot of the bandwidth, so having a drive on the USB port unless a separate port will probably be a problem - it will be a problem if running both at the same time. The Nvidia 745M is not the fastest graphic card but is a fast graphics card none the less as Nvidia gets their drivers straightened out for SLI people (running more than one monitor to view on) but the card is faster and will run better than my just bought GTX 650Ti graphics card from them. http://www.geforce.com/ As to USB 3 ports, probably not needed, just USB 2.0 ports, as about everything made for audio is still USB 2.0 and need not be any faster. According to RME it can handle 100 channels which is like 50 in and 50 out before you would have to go something called a MADI interface. Like 24 channels in and out is like nothing to USB 2.0 if the computer if set up correctly to turn off what is not needed and tweaking it to work as a DAW like it should be. If more than one USB hub then you probably can use the computer, if not, then not with an external Harddrive working off of the USB port and there seems to be nothing else to run it with (the harddrive). Might want to look around and see if there is a better laptop out there, although if not recording many, many tracks in audio and using soft synths a lot then I suppose a 5400 RPM harddrive would work also. Depends on what you record or if you use many soft synths I suppose. I got 54 tracks of audio (wave type) out of my old computer which I am sure was only 3Gb/sec or whatever transfer from the harddrive. Usually like I said the new computers are all 6Gb/sec transfer so if only a 5400 RPM harddrive perhaps you can find one that has a 7200 RPM harddrive. And the USB ports only have three probably on the same hub will make it difficult to run a heavy use USB device on the laptop and probably would limit you with that. As to audio/interfaces there are many USB type, and Focusrite, Roland, RME, usually are pretty good ones, and check latency for Roland may have slower latencies (using usually again soft-synths- look for other threads here on the forum for discussions on that). http://www.sweetwater.com/c695--USB_Audio_Interfaces One of a few on-line places or your local store if needed to order an audio/interface. The computer looks like a normal general computing laptop with a tendency towards faster computing, but like usual anymore to cut the cost of the computer, a few compremises seem to have been made. The number of USB ports (depending on how many hubs to run those) and the hard disk drive speed. Otherwise the rest is fine, and those two things may be a problem depending on how you use the laptop for recording. Can't use more bandwidth on the USB ports then what is the norm. On my system the system bandwidth for the USB port is 20%, and my RME Babyface is using 16% of the bandwidth (on one USB hub - there are two in my computer being a desktop - so a harddrive could go on the other USB hub - some thing you probably do not have on that laptop - could check by getting up device manager and seeing how many USB hubs are on that laptop). That is the fault of that computer for audio recording. (and more memory in the computer if ever needed I suppose depending again on how much and how you record audio or use soft synths.) Enough babbling I suppose. Oh, as a sidenote, a 64-bit computer is fine (probably is with that laptop) but with 64-bit computers running 64-bit programs I suppose it is not running actually any faster then a 32-bit program on a 32-bit OS computer. What I am using right now is still 32-bit Sonar as I have not upgraded yet. Don't know if that makes a difference since what I do, I can still use a bit older software but may upgrade soon, if I think it works correctly. ?? on the laptop then as you suspect.
post edited by spacealf - 2013/10/16 16:18:34
|
spacealf
Max Output Level: -54 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2133
- Joined: 2010/11/18 17:44:34
- Status: offline
Re: New Laptop and HD speed question
2013/10/16 22:47:33
(permalink)
Should have said USB hubs, as there are two in my newer computer (computer CPU not as good or as fast perhaps). One used for babyface and other used for whatever I suppose. I'm thinking the laptop only would have one, but it does pay to check the specifications of the laptop and not believe any clerk from Best Buy perhaps! OH, make sure the USB 3 ports are backwards compatible to run USB 2.0 devices. Someone said there can be a difference I guess, but then I have a USB 3 port also and I am only running USB 2 devices, since I have both type ports on my computer. About video card in the laptop: http://www.geforce.com/hardware/notebook-gpus/geforce-gt-745m/specifications Can't think of anything else right now.
post edited by spacealf - 2013/10/16 23:01:52
|
Musikman
Max Output Level: -86 dBFS
- Total Posts : 220
- Joined: 2008/08/26 11:21:27
- Location: NorthEast, USA
- Status: offline
Re: New Laptop and HD speed question
2013/10/17 00:41:31
(permalink)
Thanks for the detailed reply spacealf, I appreciate your taking the time. Seems you have noticed a few of the same things that I have where there could be potential issues, and you have also brought up a couple of things that I was not aware of. I will probably use the wi-fi and the built in webcam, wi-fi to access internet and webcam for video music lessons among other reasons. However, I'm hoping both can easily be turned on and off with a click or two of the mouse, that way when I'm going to be doing a recording session there will be no interference from either one. When you say wi-fi interferes with audio recording, how exactly do you mean? Does it just take up RAM that Sonar could be using, or interfere in a different way? Just curious. Yeah, that's what I have now, Win XP, lol, I wish they could have stopped there because XP seems to be one of the more stable OS. I am a little concerned about using Windows 8, not because I can't learn it, but just for the fact that I don't know how stable it really is, and I haven't even begun to research how compatible Sonar and Windows 8 are, so I don't know if I'm in for a world of trouble there, or if they're going to run like a charm together, we'll see I guess! I will also likely upgrade my Sonar Producer 8.5 to one of the Sonar X versions in the near future. This particular ASUS laptop seems to have a decent spec list for the price, and I'm not able to spend more than that, that would be the high end of my affordability range. Pretty sure you can see the specs on that link to the Best Buy page I posted btw, you just have to click on the tab on that page that says "specifications" and you'll get a pretty extensive list of specifications for that one. (the hard drive speed is not listed though) As for the USB ports, I was disappointed there are only 3, and I don't know if it's only one hub or not. Can't I buy an external USB hub that will allow me to have several more USB ports available? Pretty sure those are backwards compatible btw, should be able to run both ver 2 and ver 3. Like I said before, I've learned a thing or two about PCs, but I'm no computer geek by any stretch, so anyone replying please keep the lingo simple to understand, I appreciate that! ;-) As for the HD RPM, the Best Buy rep had to go to a website (I assume the ASUS website) to verify the exact drive speed of 5400RPM. He was hard pressed to find me a laptop with a 7200RPM drive speed, in fact I think he said there wasn't a single one on the sales floor that came with a 7200RPM drive. That kinda puzzles me why they would be so scarce, especially when guys like me are out there everywhere, needing them and looking for that extra speed! What he offered to me was that the Best Buy Geek Squad would put in a 7200RPM drive for me, but they would have to charge me $99 for the one year extended warranty and they would put the labor under that coverage for free, but would have to charge me $60 for the Windows backup disc they would use to transfer the OS and data with. (something like that, I don't remember exactly). But they didn't say they would credit me what the 5400RPM drive costed towards the price of the 7200RPM drive they would install. That is still something I'd like to try to negotiate with them. I know I could run an external HD but I might be better off with having the internal be 7200RPM and just use an external to store my project data, which is what an external is supposed to be for. I ran an external for playing back projects and recording for quite some time, and ended up burning out the external drive, they're just not made to take all that activity I guess. The video card does seem to be very fast, and although not Nividia's fastest, this Laptop does get high reviews from some of the gaming forums I've seem from googling this model laptop. Many of the gamers are buying this model, so there's something to be said for the speed of it for sure. This laptop RAM is expandable to 16GB, I assume that's plenty to run audio. I use soft synths, but I do run heavy on audio tracks, not only from recording my straight audio keyboards, but many times I end up converting the soft synth midi tracks to audio. So to answer your question, yes, I do run heavy on audio tracks. Typically my projects have anywhere from 15 up to 40 audio tracks when complete. I do submixes eventually too, but still, more audio tracks than midi for sure. Thanks for the link to audio interfaces, I am familiar with Sweetwater and a few other sites. My main concern is that I can run 4 ins and 4 outs with my Delta66 card right now, that is two stereo inputs for my keyboards, and two stereo outputs for monitoring, so I hope to find an interface that will handle similar capacity, hopefully without breaking my budget. As for the 32bit vs 64bit thing, you've got me there, I've always run on 32bit, so I have no clue if 64bit is going to be faster or better or anything like that. I'm going to be jumping light years compared to what I'm using now, lol, so this is going to be totally space age to me! Kinda like when television was first invented! lol :-)
post edited by Musikman - 2013/10/17 00:44:20
Sonar Platinum, Win10 Pro 64bit, AMD FX 6300 6 Core, 8GB RAM, AMD Radeon R9-380
|
spacealf
Max Output Level: -54 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2133
- Joined: 2010/11/18 17:44:34
- Status: offline
Re: New Laptop and HD speed question
2013/10/17 15:50:11
(permalink)
In programming there are items (objects since it is object oriented programming) that are called Deferred Procedure Calls, this and perhaps some other drivers also use that to run (the hardware). If the Deferred Procedure Call takes too much time (and it should not.....but) then it will interfere with steaming of audio and video every time it runs. Some run like clockwork, so every often you get this routine running on the computer that leads to a spike slowing down the streaming audio or video at regular intervals. http://www.thesycon.de/deu/latency_check.shtml http://support.microsoft.com/kb/244617 I have Windows 7, but most of it will apply to Windows 8 also probably. I mean if there is a spike like the graph shows with latency checker, then there is a problem, and a lot of times it will be a network problem like a wi-fi on the computer. Oh DPC on the second link is a shortcut meaning - Deferred Procedure Calls (DPC's). (computer terminologies ??) The second link to microsoft is just something I found out recently and did not even know I had it in XP on my old computer. It won't solve everything though, but then I have no problems like some others and their computers especially playing just a computer game. One such program to see (and this program is free vs. some others which are not) if any routine running in the background is interfering with steaming audio or video (and that is what you are doing with Sonar actually or listening to music or watching a video) is to use this program although there is a better one that was mentioned on this forum or somewhere on a game forum (but again that program is not free). I can not remember the name of it, but I sure a search will show it when searching for a latency checker program. In Windows 7 which is what I use, I turn off all the automatic stuff (Windows Update) (drivers update)(a lot of stuff actually that does not need to run although then you have to do it manually - like defrag your harddisk drive at times and other things - some people do this at night and leave the computer on and schedule it at that time to run which can be changed) and put up with doing all of that automatic stuff at the time I want to. Every month on the second Tuesday, Microsoft comes out with their updates (which right now I think have about 250 of them since Windows 7 came out) so I update about then or when I think of it. (there are enough automatic update programs still on my computer and if I am connected to the Internet, those may show up to download (which is still a setting instead of automatically doing it) so that is why when recording audio or using Sonar, I turn the Internet off (disable it). There are other tweaks as it is called to do with the OS that are "on" automatically so actually one has to get up control panel, go through all the icons and use Device Manager also and see what is in the computer in the first place concerning the OS and hardware. Unfortunately with wi-fi or anything like that if it interferes and you disable it in Device Manager, you probably have to restart your computer so the drivers are not loaded up, and that is perhaps. With my cable connection I do not have to restart my computer to "disable" or "enable" the Internet connection. I made a desktop icon to my Local Area Connection page where my Internet connection is, so I can "disable" it or "enable" it when I am on or off of the Internet. Since I do not know about wi-fi, then hopefully that could be treated the same way (because that probably also would be in the Local Connection page Window) and that would take care of that. In other words, I am sure my new computer is not all that fast so I am not sure either, but then I still can use XP and my old computer for what I do. (the signature holds a few songs, some not redone again with the little I have done - since I do not do that much). The Asus website would be the place perhaps to check the computer out a bit more and perhaps get details to make sure, but then I have not looked at their website in a while either. Just perhaps put the model number of the computer you want to buy into a search engine on the Internet, and then you probably will get reviews, and the Asus website and all of that in the search. As to the harddisk drive, perhaps it would be just better to spend the extra and have Best Buy put in the 7200 RPM drive, although I usually do all that stuff myself but only in a desktop computer. I afraid that with a laptop, I would have to have them do the work somewhere, and pay the cost of that. I am sure my newer computer would not handle a lot of soft synths since I just bought it off the shelf because I did not want Windows 8 (too strange at first for me) and wanted a Windows 7 computer and that floor model is about the only one that they had left in the store besides all the other computers having Windows 8 on those. So I ended up with what I ended up with because every place else only had Windows 8 computers. I have since found out all this stuff in Windows 7, and I will say for the most part it is better (like Windows 8 will be) but finding out that the OS is now made where most people must be dumb about computers, so the OS is like the Administrator instead of the person owning the computer or running it bummed me out at first. But a lot of that (all of probably) can be changed around and all the automatic stuff turned off. Schedules like defrag, other things to numerous to mention, like USB ports turning off power when not being used (leave on all the time) and power settings (like XP) turned on so it is on all the time like the hard disk drive and computer monitor has to be thoroughly checked in Windows 7 and probably Windows 8. (hiberation on a computer I do not run and the mouse never wakes up the computer and stuff like that). But with a laptop, to conserve battery power, most of those things are going to be set to turn off power when the computer is not being used as to make it seem like the battery lasts longer. So right now, I probably would not like a laptop as much as a desktop computer because I would want to turn all that stuff off, and run it that way that I want to, which in the end would end up using battery power and charging it back up all the time sooner than perhaps the original way the computer was set up. But one thing is that when recording audio, you do not want any thing necessarily to interfere with the running of your computer and deferred procedureal calls doing anything like taking too much time would end the recording, cause drop outs and like playing a computer game, something interfering while playing the game means that the game does not run correctly, may lag, may drop out, whatever the problem is. Audio recording demands tweaking the machine so it runs the best it can and not have anything cause a problem, but there are more demanding tasks that a computer can be used for like video and anything like that. So being aware of how the computer OS operates and what is set in the OS is just getting real familiar with the computer and then knowing what can be done about it to eliminate the problem if one occurs. And I think if you check about USB hubs I think adding one will not add anything to your computer, but I am not sure. I have two hubs, and you will have to check out that laptop you want to buy (do a search with the model number, somewhere there are better specs given than what Best Buy gave for it - even it is is the Asus website) and find out about any of that. That is a motherboard chip with the USB hubs and if it is not on the motherboard to begin with I doubt if you can add an external hub (still running off of the only other hub or maybe a PCI-e slot for expansion (or PCI) you probably do not have) to add it. A laptop is kind of set for what you can have, and a desktop computer is one you can add hardware to (if you have enough slots and some have more slots then others). So with the laptop you will have to be happy with what it has in it because that is all it will have in it probably. But since all I ever had is a desktop computer, I suppose all of that can be searched for on the Internet and read about also, just to make sure. None of those two linked programs are hard to do, unless it is something really strange in the computer and that - probably will not happen. Especially in verifier.exe program, just mark the drivers you want to check (if you even use that program ever - which probably will not) and run the computer for awhile to find out anything. I doubt that program does anything that much that some good ol' fashioned thinking could not do either running a stupid computer, and a computer is thoroughly very stupid. Only runs with the programs that been programmed into it. Of course on my computer I use logical harddrives for my one harddisk (i have another to put in I have not yet) so my one big harddrive has several partitions. The c:\ drive, and the e:\, f:\, g:\, h:\, and I:\ drives since if the C:\ drive ever fails, it does not take all the other stuff with it and all the logical drives can be read even if the C:\drives fails with the OS on it, so after putting in a new harddrive and all of that, the rest of the information (data) can be transferred over to the new harddrive ( and then throwing it away after installing it first to read it all as a second drive) and all of that. The only part that fails perhaps is the C:\ drive since that holds the OS and is used more then usually the rest of all the logical drives.
post edited by spacealf - 2013/10/17 16:29:09
|
spacealf
Max Output Level: -54 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2133
- Joined: 2010/11/18 17:44:34
- Status: offline
Re: New Laptop and HD speed question
2013/10/17 16:43:54
(permalink)
If they have the computer set up at the store (a demo computer) then get up device manager (or have the clerk do it perhaps depending how the mood is) and look at Device Manager for the USB hubs. If you have two hubs the like the picture with the Intel (R) 7 Series/C216 Chipset Family USB Enhanced Host Controllers then you will see what Device Manager lists in the computer for motherboard hardware in that aspect of the computer. Well, babbled probably too much, but that is about it. (with any computer).
|
spacealf
Max Output Level: -54 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2133
- Joined: 2010/11/18 17:44:34
- Status: offline
Re: New Laptop and HD speed question
2013/10/17 17:03:20
(permalink)
I am sure someone else here can add a post also perhaps. But even with audio/interfaces, like Motu, Roland, Focusrite, RME, probably being the best for drivers perhaps, then making sure drivers will be available for Windows 8,or Windows 8.1 or Windows 7 or whatever are available. I know RME has drivers, but that is all I know since that is what I am using. Anyone else on this forum can chime in with a post also, but like with all things: Let the consumer beware. http://www.rme-audio.de/en_index.php Well, one can read all day on the Internet, time to get up and move around and make like being alive I guess. And maybe you may want a single 2Tb harddrive but again I rather use two harddrives and my 1Tb harddrive partitioned off is way more than enough room for me and maybe some soft synths in the future. Otherwise, you will have to decide how much you need and what you can spend. Me, well, for right now, I am on the cheap side of anything. Pink Floyd songs comes to mind now: Money, it's a gas!
|
Musikman
Max Output Level: -86 dBFS
- Total Posts : 220
- Joined: 2008/08/26 11:21:27
- Location: NorthEast, USA
- Status: offline
Re: New Laptop and HD speed question
2013/10/17 23:31:36
(permalink)
I have been able to turn off what I don't want running in the background on my XP computer, so I'll just have to find out how that all works in Windows 8 and do the same. One of the things that has been helpful is having CCleaner free app, which enables me to easily disable or enable programs that run at startup, which are often some of the types of things you mentioned. If you can disable them from starting, then usually you don't have to worry about them until you decide you want to turn them on manually. As for wi-fi, sounds like you've got that covered, I don't know much about easy ways to turn that on and off, I know in my phone there is a toggle switch and can easily be disabled if I want to, hopefully it's the same or similar with a laptop. Maybe someone else who reads this can shed some light on that subject with a quick post? I'm beginning to understand what you mean about the USB hubs now. So buying a separate USB adapter with extra ports is likely not going to give me what I need since they will be running off the hub(s) that are in the laptop and not really adding hubs, only extra ports. However, I remember looking into those for my regular PC awhile back and I thought the salesperson said they are "powered" USB adapters, don't know if that makes any difference or not. I don't really know enough about them at the moment. Good idea though to check the device manager in the demo laptop at the store, will do that next time I go there, thanks! Thanks for the links, I do remember someone here posting a free latency check program quite awhile ago, but can't remember the name of it. Probably will come up by doing a forum search for "latency checker" or something like that. I've never had to use one, but in this case it seems it would be a handy tool to have. I really would like someone to elaborate more on the audio interface, and what would be a good one, especially now that you mention the drivers being a possible issue. I've never done well with drivers, for some reason it's always been one of those things that drives me nuts trying to install or uninstall properly, just a pain in the ass imo! So I'd like to get an audio interface that's not going to require me to be a computer geek to install it and its drivers, if someone here would be so kind as to post a few suggestions. I'll probably go with the standard setup of running Sonar on the "C" drive in the laptop, also running the projects off of the same "C" drive, but storing backups of the project files on a separate external HD. In the past I've found it easy to store them on external HD by just saving projects as CW Bundle files. That way everything stays together, and when changes are made you can just overwrite the existing bundle file with the new one. There are several ways to do it I guess. Seeing as how I usually end up with a lot of audio tracks, running both the Sonar software and the project itself off the faster 7200RPM drive seems to make sense, and then just using the external for backup. I seem to remember someone telling me awhile back that when you run a project off the external, you are also limited to the bottleneck of the USB transfer/playback speed as well. I have found that to be true when a project has many audio tracks. Once a project becomes a certain size, there's a traffic jam when it tries to transfer too much data simultaneously through the USB. I can't verify that 100%, but I did burn out an external drive by constantly running projects off of it, they really don't seem to be designed to hold up under that much abuse.
post edited by Musikman - 2013/10/17 23:34:58
Sonar Platinum, Win10 Pro 64bit, AMD FX 6300 6 Core, 8GB RAM, AMD Radeon R9-380
|
spacealf
Max Output Level: -54 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2133
- Joined: 2010/11/18 17:44:34
- Status: offline
Re: New Laptop and HD speed question
2013/10/18 18:24:45
(permalink)
I do not know for sure, but I think powered USB hub is just power. It is the bandwidth like I stated in a previous post that has to meet the requirements also. (My RME babyface takes 16% of the allowed system reserved bandwidth total of 20% allowed from the OS - that is what Windows 7 states.) As to drivers all I can comment is on RME drivers. They have an install program now included with the drivers, and the firmware (which has changed also but on my unit not lately) is just running the program and unplugging the unit and replugging it back in (or restarting the computer - there is a readme text file always included or explanation at their website.) They now have Windows 8.1 drivers (although changes may be made if there is an error or something wrong with the drivers - usually quite quickly). And old drivers may have to be un-installed perhaps first - which the program does not include for the new drivers - found in Windows 7 in Control Panel and the icon Programs and Features just like un-installing any program on your computer you want to un-install. The new version of the drivers will not do that automatically, so if not doing that un-install first, then both drivers will be listed in Programs and Features (in Windows 7). I do not know anything about Windows 8, except how it looked on the screen at the store when I decided I did not want it at all. Other audio/interfaces may perhaps be best found out by looking at their website or e-mailing them perhaps. http://www.rme-audio.de/en_downloads.php?page=content/downloads/en_downloads_driver&subpage=content/downloads/en_downloads_driver_uc And of course Digicheck program with RME, showing frequencies of the signal going through the computer as been upgraded when they upgrade that program. (something I should have used more of). Bandwidth is found by right clicking in Device Manager on the USB Controller Hubs and selecting on the menu - Properties and getting up the appropriate Tab to show it. (in Windows 7) Actually I suppose I should find out myself what the total bandwidth is, perhaps it is like 100% and the system is using 20% reserved and the babyface is an additional 16% and if there is only 4% left or a whooping 64% left. Heck, I do not know I guess. Just thought of that so I had to add that. Well, now I am baffled again. http://support.microsoft.com/kb/884470 Ah, ah, ah I do not know quite yet, something else to look up I guess. I guess you get an error message exceeding the USB bandwidth limit. ?? Anything about Windows 8 I do not know, and getting familiar with the OS is something I won't be doing, so perhaps searching on the Internet about it may be useful. I think some others are using Windows 8 on this forum, so perhaps they are out somewhere (vacation say or something) and perhaps will post later on this thread. And since it is not in Windows XP that I know of, then none of this was known when I bought my audio/interface (RME Babyface).Oh, well, always something new to know I suppose. Edit post again for additional info concerning USB controllers.
post edited by spacealf - 2013/10/18 22:15:43
|
spacealf
Max Output Level: -54 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2133
- Joined: 2010/11/18 17:44:34
- Status: offline
Re: New Laptop and HD speed question
2013/10/18 23:04:55
(permalink)
I just found out with Utility Programs for Windows 7 that I can because I have checked the hardware of my Windows 7 computer download Virtual PC and XP mode for my computer. I thought I already had that on my computer but trying to install old software for XP and making it XP Service Pack whatever compatible - did not seem to do it, now with this XP install Utility for my Windows 7 computer, perhaps some old programs on my XP computer will run in a XP virtual mode (which makes the OS of Windows 7 like 17Gb bigger.) Maybe there will be a difference for that now, maybe not. http://windows.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/download-utilities#utabs=win7 Might want to check Microsoft for Windows 8 Utilities to see whatever can be had for a free download also after validation of the OS according to Microsoft. Now I have to download XP mode for my Windows 7 and then back to the question of bandwidth of USB controllers, and adding a controller according to that link may satisfy your problem or not for your new computer. Afterall I may not run my old computer games, but I am sure I have a couple of programs that run on my XP computer, that perhaps may install on my Windows 7 computer now. Bonkersville time! music - do I even have time for it after all this computer OS running around in bonkersville! What else can I have perhaps?? I had the hardware to install this afterall, and first that is needed before any of it could be downloaded. ?? - always the questions - answers not so much perhaps!
|
spacealf
Max Output Level: -54 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2133
- Joined: 2010/11/18 17:44:34
- Status: offline
Re: New Laptop and HD speed question
2013/10/18 23:44:12
(permalink)
My brain is fried as of now. Bong! I think even if you add a USB controller and have it hooked up to an existing controller, then the problem still will exist for bandwidth and power. Just my opinion but probably so the way it looks. If you have 2 controllers on that laptop, then no problem. (although explained down below one controller you may not have access to to use anyway.) http://www.tomshardware.c...ase-bandwidth-windows7http://technet.microsoft..../library/cc772242.aspxhttp://www.faultwire.com/...th-Exceeded-*1553.htmlhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USB Bong! That is all I can gather from this. Adding a controller on top of an existing controller will not solve the problem if there is one using USB devices. Break time. I had the Wiki page up for USB hubs where more was explained but then I did not get the link copied but that can be clicked on with the wikilink that is there already by reading the page. I am thinking that since the OS takes 20% of the bandwidth for whatever, and the RME Babyface takes 16% which leaves only 64% left of the bandwidth of the controller that a device like a camera or also perhaps an external hard drive that needs up to 70% of the bandwidth, then it would not work on the same controller. It would be short by 6%. But in that laptop you also have a webcam and skype whatever and perhaps you have two controllers but those probably run off of a USB hub controller also. So also then depending, if they take more than 10% along with the system reserved by the OS adds up to more than 30%, then a 70% device perhaps like an external harddisk or camera, then that would also not work depending again on how much bandwidth (or power) those devices use. Perhaps you can disable those in Device Manager, but then again do you have access to the controller and perhaps you would not have access to it like the other 3 ports on the laptop. Again then there would be that problem with the laptop and depending on the audio/interface, you could not run the external harddisk and the audio/interface on the same controller. I do not know, perhaps that is something that can be searched for on the Internet also before shelling out any money for anything then.
post edited by spacealf - 2013/10/19 00:14:49
|
slartabartfast
Max Output Level: -22.5 dBFS
- Total Posts : 5289
- Joined: 2005/10/30 01:38:34
- Status: offline
Re: New Laptop and HD speed question
2013/10/19 03:13:47
(permalink)
5400 rpm drives in laptops are standard because the primary design imperative is battery life, and the secondary imperative is cooling. Slower drives run cooler and use less power, and most people buying laptops are getting machines that are already way more powerful than they will ever use for office apps and web surfing. A slow drive makes no difference for the masses of laptop users, and extra hour of battery life will make or break the machine in the market. Putting a hot drive in a laptop that is not spec'ed for that may lead to heat problems. If you want to fully utilize a fast external drive, there is the possibility of a bottleneck on USB 2. Fast SATA drives with large buffers mounted in external enclosures may actually be able to move data faster than USB 2 can handle. eSATA ports are rare if not non-existent in laptops, so USB 3 may be the fastest you can practically feed the drive. Be aware that many of the actual hard drives in external drive boxes are not super fast and not a few are "green" by design meaning either the controller in the enclosure, or the drive itself will power down to save energy which may screw up real time data transfer if it has to rev up during a slow cycle to accept your data.
|
spacealf
Max Output Level: -54 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2133
- Joined: 2010/11/18 17:44:34
- Status: offline
Re: New Laptop and HD speed question
2013/10/19 14:10:00
(permalink)
I was just thinking (guessing) that perhaps the audio/interface would also use and need more bandwidth depending on how many channels are being recorded or played at one time. Like with my RME Babyface, the 16% would go up higher and higher if all inputs were being used - just guessing and I don't know for sure. ?? Seems reasonable though that bandwidth depends on what is being done on the USB port.
|
Musikman
Max Output Level: -86 dBFS
- Total Posts : 220
- Joined: 2008/08/26 11:21:27
- Location: NorthEast, USA
- Status: offline
Re: New Laptop and HD speed question
2013/10/22 12:41:05
(permalink)
Thanks for the input guys. So you are obviously aware of these speed/heat issues. The reasons I wanted to get a laptop was convenience, portability, plus many of the laptops have five times the speed in CPU and RAM than my current desktop PC does. Another reason I want a laptop is that it's quieter than my desktop, the fan noise from my desktop gets in the background of vocal tracks, so I'd really rather not get another desktop. So despite the quick speed of a laptop such as the ASUS I'm looking at, I may be severely restricted by the USB bottle neck if I have to use the 5400RPM drive with an external 7200RPM?? That sucks! Is there any other possible solution? I'm wondering how much of an overheating risk it is to install a 7200RPM to replace the original that comes with the laptop? I am aware of the "green" externals, they are a pain in the butt. I burned one out using it to play my Sonar projects, and it does interfere with audio play. I almost lost all my data, luckily I had it double backed up on another drive. They are not made to take the abuse, that's for sure. I would definitely need to go with USB 3 instead of ver 2, though I don't know enough about them to know how much more data can be moved through a USB 3 compared to a USB 2. Still don't like the fact that it will be restricted, because let's face it, if the USB is going to only go so fast, what's the point in getting a machine that is quad core processor with 8GB RAM if it's not going to be put to it's full use?? I'd like to hear from some others here who maybe already have a laptop setup and have tested these scenarios. I would appreciate any suggestions. Before I go out and spend $$$ on a laptop I'd like to know that it's not going to choke if I need to run a big audio project file, and I'd like to know what might be my absolute best setup scenario that will utilize my laptop's speed to the fullest.
Sonar Platinum, Win10 Pro 64bit, AMD FX 6300 6 Core, 8GB RAM, AMD Radeon R9-380
|
slartabartfast
Max Output Level: -22.5 dBFS
- Total Posts : 5289
- Joined: 2005/10/30 01:38:34
- Status: offline
Re: New Laptop and HD speed question
2013/10/22 13:45:28
(permalink)
USB 3.0 is theoretically much much faster than USB 2.0, and is probably fast enough to saturate the write capacity of a 7200 rpm drive in actual real world use. In other words unless you are feeding an SSD via USB 3.0, the bottleneck is likely to be your 7200 rpm drive's sustained write speed rather than the USB pipe. http://www.macworld.com/article/2039427/how-fast-is-usb-3-0-really-.html
|
Musikman
Max Output Level: -86 dBFS
- Total Posts : 220
- Joined: 2008/08/26 11:21:27
- Location: NorthEast, USA
- Status: offline
Re: New Laptop and HD speed question
2013/10/22 23:53:49
(permalink)
That is an encouraging thread, thanks for the link, much appreciated, although there was some dispute in the posts that followed further down. If USB 3 is that fast then I should have no problem as long as I don't get an external that is "green". That shutdown feature is definitely annoying to say the least, kinda like how my DVR drive operates when I'm watching a video disc and changing scenes, same thing happens. Like the DVR drive has to establish an initial read on the same disc over and over. (There's gotta be a work around for that, I just don't know it I guess!) I am still curious as to what extent, if any, replacing the internal 5400RPM HDD with a 7200RPM would cause overheating issues. How much hotter does the 7200RPM run that it would make that much difference? I don't have a clue as to the answer to that, just curious if anyone thinks it's worth a try.
post edited by Musikman - 2013/10/23 00:10:52
Sonar Platinum, Win10 Pro 64bit, AMD FX 6300 6 Core, 8GB RAM, AMD Radeon R9-380
|