[Solved]Rapture Pro and Sustain pedal problem

This is my first post here. I bought Rapture Pro yesterday. There are many nice piano sounds inside Rapture Pro, but there are little problem too. Rapture Pro does not respond my Roland Sustain pedal when i play it with my Roland Keyboard via midi caple. I don't get it. It respond it when i try play Rapture Pro with my Computer Keyboard and push Sustain Pedal down. Very strange. Maybe i should start practicing Computer Keyboard playing or maybe there are somewhere some solution for this problem. Anyone? 
 
Ps. I didin't have this kind of  problems with other programs. (Z3ta+2, old Rapture, Dimension Pro, Cakewalk Sound Center, Lounge Lizard Session 4, TruePianos etc)

Any idea how to add Rapture Pro some sustain manually because Rapture Pro don't like to respond my physical sustain pedal?

Thanx. Have to try it some day. 
 
Rapture Pro still need some fixing.

brundlefly
Which Roland keyboard. Is the pedal on/off only, or continuous? Some synths respond incorrectly to All Notes Off that some old Roland keyboards (like my RD-300s) send on last key up, letting it override sustain. Actually, TruePianos has this issue. I don't usually use Rapture for pianos, but I just tried several in Rapture Pro, and they responded correctly to sustain from the RD-300s, so I'm not sure what the problem might be in your case, but I don't think it's a defect in Rapture Pro. I checked with continuous pedal from my RD-700NX, and that worked fine as well.

"Is the pedal on/off only, or continuous?"
 
Both. There are switch that i can choose witch one.
My sustain pedal is Roland DP-10.
 
I have tried my Roland BK-5 and M-Audio keyboard with that pedal. In either, Rapture Pro don't responding sustain pedal. I just don't know what i'm doing wrong.
 
With TruePianos it work's great and with everyone else. Only Rapture Pro, nothing happens.
 
 
 
 
 
 

It probably is necessary. The several pianos i tried all worked, but some had such a long release programmed and such a steep decay in the sustain phase that the difference was not as clear as usual. So it would be good to know which patches we're talking about, especially if any are not pianos.

That one also sustains as expected for me. I really have no idea what would cause the problem you're describing that wouldn't affect other synths as well. Still, it might be worth putting a MIDI monitor utility like MIDI-OX on the input port to see what's coming from the keyboard when you play notes and sustain at the same time. Possibly it's sending something that non-programmable synths don't respond to.
 
Also, that Almost Together patch is a Dim Pro patch, so maybe try loading it up in Dim Pro and seeing if you get the same behavior. 

Hello odyssey70, I'm not able to readily reproduce your issue. It seems like there may be something specific to how your Roland controller is talking to Rapture Pro that is causing the problem. I'd recommend getting a hold of our Technical Support team who can take a more in-depth look at what's going on with your setup. 

https://youtu.be/1ivae_PmdiU
 
I made a video looking for an event that might help explain, but I'm not sure I've helped at all.

I still check the both keyboard controllers with MIDI-OX. I found one different. MidiPlus use Channel 1 and Roland BK-5 use Channel 4 when they sending data. 
 
MidiPlus controller:
 
0002A333 1 2 90 3E 00 1 D 4 Note Off
0002A3C9 1 2 90 3C 00 1 C 4 Note Off
00030665 1 2 B0 40 7F 1 --- CC: Pedal (Sustain)
00030699 1 2 B0 40 00 1 --- CC: Pedal (Sustain)
00030D14 1 2 90 34 51 1 E 3 Note On
00030DBA 1 2 90 34 00 1 E 3 Note Off
00031020 1 2 90 2F 49 1 B 2 Note On
 
Roland BK-5
 
00024BCC 1 2 93 3C 4F 4 C 4 Note On
00024C10 1 2 93 3B 00 4 B 3 Note Off
00024C93 1 2 93 3C 00 4 C 4 Note Off
00024E03 1 2 B3 40 7F 4 --- CC: Pedal (Sustain)
00024E0E 1 2 F0 Buffer: 17 Bytes System Exclusive
SYSX: F0 41 10 00 00 54 12 18 00 02 15 08 00 07 0F 33 F7
00024F6D 1 2 B3 40 00 4 --- CC: Pedal (Sustain)
00024F74 1 2 F0 Buffer: 17 Bytes System Exclusive
SYSX: F0 41 10 00 00 54 12 18 00 02 15 08 00 00 00 49 F7
00025151 1 2 B3 40 7F 4 --- CC: Pedal (Sustain)
00025156 1 2 F0 Buffer: 17 Bytes System Exclusive
SYSX: F0 41 10 00 00 54 12 18 00 02 15 08 00 07 0F 33 F7
00025248 1 2 B3 40 00 4 --- CC: Pedal (Sustain)
00025250 1 2 F0 Buffer: 17 Bytes System Exclusive
SYSX: F0 41 10 00 00 54 12 18 00 02 15 08 00 00 00 49 F7
0002581E 1 2 B3 40 7F 4 --- CC: Pedal (Sustain)
00025825 1 2 F0 Buffer: 17 Bytes System Exclusive
SYSX: F0 41 10 00 00 54 12 18 00 02 15 08 00 07 0F 33 F7
0002592B 1 2 B3 40 00 4 --- CC: Pedal (Sustain)
00025932 1 2 F0 Buffer: 17 Bytes System Exclusive
SYSX: F0 41 10 00 00 54 12 18 00 02 15 08 00 00 00 49 F7

brundlefly
I would still guess the SysX messages from the BK-5 are the culprit.

Yes. This could be the reason why Rapture Pro don't give a sustain. TruePiano and others still works with Roland BK and with these SysX messages. 
 
I have to check if there are possibility turn off these kind messages from BK-5 some how.

FWIW, I too am having issues with the sustain pedal not working with an Alesis Q88 in Rapture Session. It works fine in Dimension Pro. Rapture completely ignores it. The issue is also in the other sections of Rapture as well.
 
Not a big deal as I rarely use Rapture but if Sonar is going solely to Rapture then it needs to be fixed.

WOW - thanks so much for your post.  I have no idea how my settings changed but this is exactly what happened to me too.  Marked the box and my sustain pedal is back up and working.   Thx.

Great, i'm glad it's working now :)