The Grass is always Greener... Not Always...

Author
jquenneville
Max Output Level: -90 dBFS
  • Total Posts : 1
  • Joined: 2015/01/17 18:01:21
  • Status: offline
2017/12/24 06:09:55 (permalink)

The Grass is always Greener... Not Always...

I was saddened by the announcement that no further development will take place on the fine Cakewalk software products. I've been a customer for some time, going back to the "Pro audio" days, and even had exposure to the very early days when it was just MIDI.
 
Now, in interest of full disclosure, I am a semi-professional musician, and pay the bills during the day as a software engineer. I pay attention to stability, performance, features, and of course, ease of use. For whatever reason, I found the Cakewalk interfaces easy to use. (Sonar, Instruments, effects) Generally, the software has been stable, and performs well on various platforms. I've never had a situation where files have been corrupt and lost work.
 
I've heard a lot of noise about competing products, Pro Tools specifically. I wondered to my self, does any serious producer/engineer/studio use Sonar, or do they all use Pro Tools? Well, let's see what happens when this semi-pro ventures into the so-called "serious" or "professional" world of Digital Audio Workstations.
 
Where do I start? How about install/licensing? Sonar has a straight forward simple way of licensing and securing their software. Avid, not so much. After install of Pro Tools, I have a tray application, and a couple of "helper" applications. Do I really need network traffic while working on my latest platinum hit? I gotta wonder how the big studios put up with that. Anyone that has worked with DAWs will know controlling network access/activity is critical. I have two processes consuming about 200MB just on boot, without even invoking the application. 
 
Next would be the memory footprint. Compared to Sonar, the footprint to run Pro Tools is more like a tank track than a foot print. Starting the program spawns additional processes, not to mention the aforementioned tray application. So in an "apples to apples" comparison, Sonar can start up and initialize in a few seconds, while I've been able to write this paragraph while waiting for Pro Tools to come up. "Pro Tools (Not Responding)". It spawned two additional processes, while eating an additional 400MB+ just to initialize. It is still not up, nor do I think it will ever come up at this point.
 
So what's my point? After having Sonar "discontinued", I thought "oh well, time to move on". The problem is where to go? So far all I've seen as an alternative is not an alternative; not even close. 
 
Business is business, and if Cakewalk can't survive then there is nothing that can be done. However, software doesn't rust and I'll continue to use Sonar as long as my hardware and O/S will let me. You should consider the same.
#1

1 Reply Related Threads

    jyoung60
    Max Output Level: -72 dBFS
    • Total Posts : 914
    • Joined: 2015/09/01 11:00:11
    • Location: Nova Scotia, Canada
    • Status: offline
    Re: The Grass is always Greener... Not Always... 2017/12/24 11:24:34 (permalink)
    It's hard to advise where to go, because everyone has their own requirements, workflow, and learning curve tolerance.  I've chosen Reaper because it suits me best for all three of those things.  By default it is right-click dependent (menus galore, but awesome options upon options upon options), but toolbars can be created if that's your style. In fact, Reaper is crazy customizable all over the place.  And a very small footprint.
     
    Plugins are another concern.  I don't use many at all, personally, so it's all good; but someone who uses them extensively may run into compatibility issues - so decisions need to be made.  There are any number of pros and cons to any DAW software.
     
    But all in all, Reaper is serving me well.  The learning curve hasn't been too bad for me, but it does take a little patience because, bottom line, it's not SONAR.  Nothing really comes close to SONAR. Unfortunately we have to carve out time to explore what's out there, and settle on one. Or two. Or three. lol

    DAW: Cakewalk by Bandlab (latest version) - x64
    VST: Roland Sound Canvas VA
    Hardware: Roland MC50mkII Sequencer; Yamaha DGX-660 keyboard; Steinberg UR-44 Interface
    OS: Windows 10 Home 64-bit
    #2
    Jump to:
    © 2025 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1