Undo Still Has Wrong Thing Listed - X3d

Hi...
 
Sorry I'm not getting the detail, please can you give us specific reproducible steps in a real world scenario.
Like
 
1) Click this.
2) Click that.
3) Press undo
 
.....  be as detailed as you can (don't summarise), Thankyou...

Yea, i can confirm that it will undo your last move when it is listing something else.

I reported this under the first release of X3, and it was confirmed. Edit > History will show the correct most recent action, but Edit > Undo will show an earlier one. As mentioned, however, it's just a labeling issue. The action that actually gets undone is correct.
 
 

Totally working here as well Alex.
 
Edit > Undo is in sync with Edit > History
 
Project started in X1, edited in X2, now opened in X3 (and I didn't even bother to rename it)

And this is reproducible all the time..?
Have you checked this with a brand new project, just with a couple of steps?
You have two people here who cannot reproduce with X3D 64 bit so some information has to be missing here, we are running the same software.
 
Cheers....

jb101 this isn't a numbers game, we are trying to find out what causes this. If there is a difference of opinion clearly we are being given the wrong steps or there is something weird going on with a particular system.
 
I'll give you my steps as nobody is giving me theirs, perhaps just ONE person who is experiencing this issue, could follow the steps:


X3D - Not something you could reproduce in the past!
 
**** A brand new project *** - Not an old project!!!!
 
Create soft synth
Record MIDI
Observe Undo Recording and it undo
 
RESULT
 
As expected.
 
Redo recording
Drag MIDI clip
Observe Undo Drag Move and undo
Observe Undo Recording and undo.

RESULT
 
As expected.
 
NOTE - History is sync every step of the way.
 
Your turn, remember a brand new project.
 
Thankyou
 
UPDATE
 
Looking at this thread again I only see one person who has stated they actually have this problem with X3D.
So if you have this problem here are my steps please follow. Thanks.

This will consistently reproduce the issue for me in X3d:
 
Steps: 
- Create a project with a single audio track containing a short clip.
- Save, close and re-open it to clear the edit history.
- Insert a second audio track and leave focus there.
- Select the clip in the first track.
- Hold Ctrl and hit C, V to copy-paste the clip to the second track.
- Hit Delete to delete the original clip.
- Right-click the first track, and choose Delete Track.
- Open the Edit menu, and note what action is shown next to Undo
- Select History, and note where that action is in the list.

Expected Results: 
- The Edit menu will show "Undo Delete Track" corresponding to the most recent action shown in History.

Actual Results:
- The Edit menu shows "Undo Insert Audio Track", which is the fourth action down in History, and the first action taken after opening the project.
- Note, incidentally, that the most recent action is shown as "De&lete Track" with an ampersand in the action description.

Looks like I can reproduce!
 

 
 
Would you mind/would it be possible to log your test case and giving me an issue number Dave?
(might as well give them a link to this thread).
 
Thanks.....

Hey, thanks for looking into this, really appreciated!

OK then I've reported it. CWBRN-22662
 

Validated again, same behaviour (not fixed X3E).