X2 - Piano Roll - Cannot select notes

Have you accidently disabled editing for the track in the prv track list? Although you should get a warning if that is the case.

Something similar happened to me when I first got X2.

The only way to get the clip functioning again was to right click on it and tell it to bounce to clip.

Yes, if I open my project, it starts with the piano roll up, but I cannot select (or edit) any notes in that piano roll. I then have to double-click on a different clip, and then select the original clip, and then it works.

It's a very short test project. Do you want me to email it to you so that you can see if it's broken for you? Or should I just send it to Cakewalk? (Though I suppose they are super-busy fixing other bugs right now)

That's because you're untalented Karl

I do. I can't edit or select them either.

I notice that they (B) are on a different channel to A but that shouldn't make them unselectable AFAIK.

Stranger still I can't change the channel in the event list either.

I'll have a deeper look and see what I can come up with but it looks like a bug to me.

Thanks swamptooth, that fixes the problem but it must be a bug or at the very least unexpected behaviour.

If notes are visible in the PRV they should be editable regardless of what the default clip editor is set to, shouldn't they?

Interesting...

This project was for testing drum-related features in X2. I first recorded both test clips via MIDI, and then started experimenting with drum maps and the step sequencer. I guess I forgot to set the default (double-click) editor for the second clip back to piano roll.

I'm relieved that there is a workaround. However, it seems really strange that the choice of default editor has the odd side effect of preventing edits in the other editors (at least the piano roll).

I think this is a bug rather than a desired feature, because there doesn't seem to be any advantage in preventing edits in editor A if editor B is the default editor. That would be like preventing edits in the Event List if the Piano Roll is the default editor, and Sonar has never worked that way.

swamptooth


Nope, because step sequencer is a separate interface. You would have to bounce the clip down and then convert it to a step sequencer clip.  SS has parameters like flam amount and swing time that are included in clips that aren't a part of standard midi clips.

I understand that and I'm now beginning to doubt my sanity because when I first opened the project, I could have sworn it was all one MIDI clip. Since re opening I can now see two clips one MIDI and one SS which explains it completely but I'm sure there was only one MIDI clip before hence my confusion. Either that or I was so zoomed in on it I could only see one.
 
@tripecac - was there only one clip or did I dream that part?
 

I think what happened to me is I clicked on the 'B' notes in the PRV shifting the now time to the B clip and drawing a note at the same time. As my TV is fairly zoomed in the now time had shifted to that clip so I assumed* they were all in one clip.

That's why I never picked up on the step sequencer clip. It is a little harder to tell now as although the clip edges are rounded there is no other indication that it is a SS clip and you are correct it has always been that you can't edit SS data in the PRV. Just previously it was a little easier to tell it was SS data.

Oh well,  live and learn... 

*bad idea - never assume always check

oh man... duh moment. lol.