Not being able to back up (for free, without some goofy service that costs money to back up an unwanted 'service' that costs money to guarantee the use of software that costs money that I paid) was one of the primary reasons I ditched anything with an external dongle of any kind.
Back when I was using Cubase (versions 2 & 3), I saw FAR too many threads about lost/stolen/broken dongles ending with the reality of the person needing to re-purchase software. Really? No way.
This is apparently better now in some ways... for now... but I honestly disagree that you're necessarily "missing out" if you give them up. For some that may be true, but I have zero dongles now, and rarely ever feel like I'm missing out on anything.
Now, internal dongles don't bother me as much. Take, for instance, UAD plugs... the cards in some sense are effectively dongles in that if you don't have the card, you don't have the plug... but at least in that case:
- the dongle actually does something
- you're not likely to lose or break it, since it's connected to the machine in a more forceful way than USB
- it's not as likely to be stolen stand-alone
But regular iLok style dongles make me nervous. I've lost them before. They turned up, eventually, but for that month's-long WTF period of literally needing to re-buy something I've rightfully purchased... sucked. I don't have another $600, and I'm a registered user, so... help me out here: NO.
Of all the copy protection schemes, a singular piece of hardware that theoretically might have thousands of dollars of stuff on it, and is little, and brittle... no way.
If they allowed back-ups, and/or stepped into the 21st century and had a way to de-authorize for a purchasing user FOR FREE, I'd think differently about them.
- zevo