The bar has always been high, it's just that nowadays the music scene is way, way over-saturated. Thanks to the convenience of the Internet and incredible yet affordability of technology.
All those freaking music sites:
{sigh} Most of these music sites are musicians who fan musicians. It's become more of a musicians social hang out. At best, their music players and other widgets.
{tip} Want to know where the #1 online music scene is? it's sites such as; YouTube.
BUT I recommend you get music video(s) released by a good distributor, get it done professionally. You will get paid per-click/view. The music video can simply be a good quality still image, a lot of well known bands do this. AND your music video will be distributed to a lot of other sites including popular magazines. Some distributors also provide good affordable kick-start marketing.
Subjectiveness has always been part of the scene, one critic says its fab the other says it's crab. A lot of famous 'awesome' bands got negative crits and still do.
Great songs along with 'real' musicianship skills is what people love to see 'live'. Also being able to actually 'entertain', to captivate the crowd is what my manager will say. So it's more than just great songs, you have to also 'deliver' (musicianship skills) and 'entertain' (showmanship). Well I don't mean, cartwheels across the stage and flying human cannons but something like that LOL!!
I had a great run from late 1970 through to mid 1990. Had two different managers (two different bands) during those years. Since about mid 1980 I also saw the DJ scene emerge and a lot of venues die. But new venues open and other opportunities are available.
{tip} Like I suggested in my first post, get a professional manager and consider other areas such as, music placement for films, jingles and games.
Good luck. Wish you great success!