PayPal for the win!
Sorry to hear of your theft MM.
A month or so ago my girlfriend purchased some perfume for her and a bottle of cologne for me.
The next day there were 3 charges pending with a total of just under $600.
All for Cheap Tickets (the site she got the perfume from happened to be Cheap Scents or something like that).
She called the bank and they closed the card. We went to open a new one for her and they were able to put the pending transaction ones back into her account within 3 days.
The bank also found one more that actually went through for another $100-ish. That one took 10 days to investigate and about 3 weeks to get the money back.
She is still leery of using her card even at restaurants, gas stations and stores like Macy's.
I told her that while credit card theft can happen pretty much anywhere, most major store's are usually pretty safe.
I told her that my guess was with the scent company.
I opened he up a PayPal account and told her use that whenever possible. I also informed her about the HTTPS thing. MAKE SURE YOU SEE THE 'S' is now drilled into her head.
But first and foremost never buy off shady sites. Try to stay with the names you know like Staples, Target, JC Penny and so on.
Not
Bapu's house of cheap slightly used VST's.
It sucks for you because you did shop through a reputable merchant. But that doesn't mean that all their employees are reputable.
All it takes is one person to be tight on the cash with a busted up car and access to your card info.
Mike