You may have forgotten about the good ol' Sonitus compressor, as I did. It seems a little antiquated by current standards, lacking some of the bells 'n whistles that have become standard features since the plugin came out in 2003 (!). No lookahead, sidechain filter, channel unlinking, M/S, auto-release, wet/dry mix, gating, or expander.
However, it does have sidechaining, a continuously-adjustable knee and is capable of high ratios. It might not be the
first choice for every compressor application, but it's quite capable for many tasks. This past weekend I discovered one such task that it's
very good at: vocal leveling.
I was playing with my recently-acquired MMultiAnalyzer. I also have SPAN Plus, which does a fine job for comparing track spectra, so I was reluctant to buy another multi-channel analyzer. But MMultiAnalyzer has a few features that make it stand apart from similar products, and the one feature that convinced me to part with the cash was its unique loudness chart.
It occurred to me that the loudness chart would let me evaluate how well different compressors and settings achieved vocal leveling. I created a project with the same vocal clip duplicated on 16 tracks, each with a different compressor and an instance of MMultiAnalyzer. I could then see the volume envelopes for each of them, overlaid atop the original raw clip. This made it very easy to compare how well each compressor was doing, and to tweak settings for best results.
Here's an example. The black trace is the raw clip, the red trace is the volume history after processing with the compressor in SONAR's Vocal Strip:
I tested every compressor I could remember ever using for vocal leveling, and some I would never have considered. There weren't a lot of surprises; the ones that had seemed to work well in the past tested well. My longtime go-to, FabFilter Pro-C scored well, as expected. But it wasn't the best. It was in fact narrowly edged out by - surprise! - the Sonitus.
Here's a plot of Pro-C (red) versus Sonitus (blue):
Honorable mention goes to another surprise contender, the free MCompressor from the Meldaproduction free bundle.
Some of the candidates that I expected to do well did not. Bottom of the list (in no particular order): Klanghelm DC1A, IKM Fairchild 670, Limiter No. 6 (just the compressor portion), and all of my FET-type compressors (e.g. RoughRider, Stillwell Rocket).
Sorry, I'm on 8.5 so I can't test ProChannel. I'd invite others to perform the same type of test with their favorite compressors. Lawajava, I'm looking at you, buddy. Let's see how your favorite (Alloy) does. I'd also be curious to look at some so-called "bus compressors" such as The Glue, as well as some of the popular do-everything comps like DC8C.
I'd be especially interested in how Meldaproduction's MDynamics does - I know a few of you have the Melda Total Bundle, so you'll have this as well as the MMultiAnalyzer plugin. On paper, MDynamics looks like the ultimate multi-purpose comp, with every feature you could ask for. The only other one that's as feature-rich is Blue Cat Dynamics, but I don't have that one, either.