I've never been happy with the results when using filters to kill power line hum... it affects the signal and it just never sounds quite right to me. Seems unlikely, since one is attenuating an octave or so where the guitar has little or no energy, but the result always sounds odd to me.
My first choice, if I weren't such a cheapskate, would be Izotope RX, although there are some really good noise reduction tools out there now, some of which probably do as good a job. Actually, my first choice would be CEDAR, but that's not happening!
However, I am cheap, and I already have the NR plugin from Sony/Sound Forge - and it works really well for this sort of task. So that's what I use<G>!
I did demo Redunoise - the noise reduction plug-in from Voxengo, and I was really happy with the results. You might give that a spin.
Good luck!