• Computers
  • WHY do we want a quiet computer? (p.2)
2013/07/15 11:25:14
Bristol_Jonesey
The only item now producing noise from inside my pc case is the CPU fan.
I'm tempted to swap it out for a different model, but I've sort of backed myself into a corner with the case.
Most of the 3rd party coolers I've seen are quite tall and my case is a 4U rack mountable.
 
Anyone have any suggestions?
 
Cheers,
 
 
Jonesey
 
2013/07/15 11:53:13
Jim Roseberry
Bristol_Jonesey
 
Most of the 3rd party coolers I've seen are quite tall and my case is a 4U rack mountable.
 
 

 
You're options for large/quality 3rd party coolers are pretty limited.
As you mentioned, most of the top-tier air coolers are too tall for a 4U Rack... and there's typically not enough space to mount the radiator/fan for a water-cooler.
 
2013/07/15 12:35:16
spacealf
Because people try and get rid of noise. They use headphones (and do not want extra noise in those) or they use a room that is actually more quiet than other rooms in the house, and some people want peace and noiselessness than noise all the time. (or they live in a big city that never sleeps!)
 
But you can have noise in your recording if you wish it, so do what you want to.
 
2013/07/15 14:14:54
paulo
I think the question is really why would you want a noisy one ?
2013/07/16 17:00:31
Bristol_Jonesey
Jim Roseberry
Bristol_Jonesey
 
Most of the 3rd party coolers I've seen are quite tall and my case is a 4U rack mountable.
 
 

 
You're options for large/quality 3rd party coolers are pretty limited.
As you mentioned, most of the top-tier air coolers are too tall for a 4U Rack... and there's typically not enough space to mount the radiator/fan for a water-cooler.
 


Yeah it's pretty crowded in there already with 3 x hard drives in silent sleeves
Thanks Jim - I might think about getting a new case and move the whole lot over.
2013/07/17 02:34:56
Goddard
You might look at "top down" coolers with horizontal or angled folded heatpipe heatsink arrangements and top-mounting fans rather than vertically-oriented tall ones with side fans.
 
The classic example back when was probably Thermaltake's Big Typhoon model but since then many other makers have offered top-down coolers for height-restrcted applications. One thing toi be aware of, they can be a right pain to mount due to the  sometimes rather limited access.
 
Fwiw, I've been pretty happy using Scythe's coolers in such applications over the years. Quiet.
2013/07/17 10:35:54
Jim Roseberry
Goddard
You might look at "top down" coolers with horizontal or angled folded heatpipe heatsink arrangements and top-mounting fans rather than vertically-oriented tall ones with side fans.
 
The classic example back when was probably Thermaltake's Big Typhoon model but since then many other makers have offered top-down coolers for height-restrcted applications. One thing toi be aware of, they can be a right pain to mount due to the  sometimes rather limited access.
 
Fwiw, I've been pretty happy using Scythe's coolers in such applications over the years. Quiet.




Socket 2011 (SandyBridge-E) and socket 1150 (Haswell) both run hot when over-clocked.
The Scythe units are great for SandyBridge/IvyBridge... but they (and many other lower-profile 3rd party coolers) are not adequate for running high-performance SandyBridge-E or Haswell in a cool/quiet manner.  In a rackmount (or other small form-factor situation), heat build-up can be an issue (especially if you're working with 80mm exhaust fans).  It's a delicate balance between desired performance, keeping temps in check, and keeping noise to a minimum.
 
2013/07/17 16:04:28
jjthomas
Why not?  I just retired a noisy video card.  My last build was designed to be a quiet computer.  I really enjoy sitting at my computer and not having to listen to the fans spinning.
 
Getting a quiet computer put together really was not that hard.
 
-JJ
2013/07/18 00:01:25
Goddard
Jim Roseberry
Goddard
You might look at "top down" coolers with horizontal or angled folded heatpipe heatsink arrangements and top-mounting fans rather than vertically-oriented tall ones with side fans.
 
The classic example back when was probably Thermaltake's Big Typhoon model but since then many other makers have offered top-down coolers for height-restrcted applications. One thing toi be aware of, they can be a right pain to mount due to the  sometimes rather limited access.
 
Fwiw, I've been pretty happy using Scythe's coolers in such applications over the years. Quiet.




Socket 2011 (SandyBridge-E) and socket 1150 (Haswell) both run hot when over-clocked.
The Scythe units are great for SandyBridge/IvyBridge... but they (and many other lower-profile 3rd party coolers) are not adequate for running high-performance SandyBridge-E or Haswell in a cool/quiet manner.  In a rackmount (or other small form-factor situation), heat build-up can be an issue (especially if you're working with 80mm exhaust fans).  It's a delicate balance between desired performance, keeping temps in check, and keeping noise to a minimum.



Another viewpoint, testing a Scythe top-down cooler on i7-3960x:
 
http://www.xbitlabs.com/a...-kama-cross-rev-b.html
 
Btw, rackmount does not necessarily mean height restriction or a small form factor; a 5U (or even 4U) case can offer sufficient height for tallish cpu coolers and large (120mm) intake and/or exhaust fans and plenty of quiet airflow.
2013/07/21 00:25:00
jm24
After learning of the google research/observations about hard disks lasting longest when running in the recommended temp range I stopped trying to cool mine. The research indicates hard drives that are too cool/too hot die sooner. Mine were being too cool.
 
I have a fanless vid card, a giant ninja cpu cooler with 120mm fan, a 120 exhaust, and a 120 on the power supply.  No intake fan.
 
the Hard disks run near the bottom of the recommended range.  Cpu rarely hits 46 , and the case is usually 6+ degrees cooler.  No central cooling in the house.  Just big trees.
 
I do understand my little computer is not a match for the i crowd.  But it is fairly quiet and cool enough.
 
Amd  phenom 2 3 core, 25% OC , 3 disks, 8 gig rams   in a standard case  laying on its side  in a rack  on a piece of foamy.
© 2025 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account