Post Message Preview
craigb
Rodar6
Huh!
feeling insulted
later
Not sure what you were expecting. Does it have to be an "A" or can it be a G##? Or a Bbb? What about A# or Ab? There's 19,320 chords just in the Ionian (Major) scale alone. Many use an "A" note. What are you looking for?
Some friendly interaction and creativity.
You're right it could be any note. Why complicate things even more.
Have you ever tried putting a different chord to the same note in a melody ( * which as you point out could be any note) and felt how it changed the style and feel of a piece.
Ever tried a Bbmaj7 instead of an A to see how it changes things over an A vocal melody note (see *)
Sorry to suggest a thread that may spark some creativity but if you cant be friendly then why bother to contribute to a thread.
May I apologise for not being able to live up to your expectations. Thanks for making my experience on the forum a sh*t one.