My son wanted to buy some active monitors and we went into a shop where they had lots set up. I must say I was very impressed with the Yamaha HS series.
(I started with them Chris because of your great recommendation) We were comparing HS5's to HS7's mainly and to other brands too. He ended up with the HS7's (manily budget) and they certainly sounded better in the bottom end than the HS5's. I believe the HS7's and 8's are similar but I could also imagine the 8's just going down that little bit further. (nice!)
So
Chris I can really see why you like the Yamaha's They are very very good indeed especially for the money. We got the 7's for $570 pair.
We had some super reference material to test with. The KRK's were nowhere and I mean nowhere compared to the Yamaha's. Completely dull and lifeless. The cheaper Mackies were OK but a little hyped in the low end and coloured. I have the HR824's and they are in a league of their own Mackie wise but they are also considerably more expensive too.
(Mine are on concrete stands and this changes a lot. The low end becomes non coloured and smoother and more extended. As a result the mids and highs move forward slightly. These speakers on concrete stands sound like a completely different speaker, hard to believe but true! Concrete stands are the ultimate) The new JBL's sounded excellent as well and were very well balanced. They (the shop) say the Yamaha's are being preferred over much more expensive monitors too.
I have lived with NS10's too for about 6 months a while back. I repaired a set for someone and had the use of them for a while. They are very forward mids and highs wise and poor in the low end. They are good for translation but I don't like long term listening on them though. The new HS series although they have a white cone that is where the similarity ends though. They are way better than NS10's. Nice low end and lovely present mids and highs that you can listen to for long periods. A well balanced speaker overall. Yes the mids and highs are also a little forward but nothing like NS10's.