2017/11/03 18:18:50
mumpcake
I heard this term not long ago and I thought I should share it.
 
Basically a countrybagger is a rock or pop artist who decides to make a country song or album as a cheap ploy for cash or attention.
 
For example, "that single by Steven Tyler would be the worst example of countrybagging I have ever heard. "
 
or "Lionel Richie just released a country album.  I would never expected him to be a countrybagger."
 
Obviously this is open to interpretation as to who qualifies or not.  If you are a rock star with heavy folk influences, then you wouldn't be one.  If you are a "hair metal" band from New Jersey that releases a country track, you just might be a countrybagger.
 
 
2017/11/03 18:26:33
Mesh
When two worlds collide?
 
 

2017/11/03 18:26:59
eph221
The democratization of the music market makes all those narratives (and poly ticks) moot. You can be whatever you want to be with authenticity.  I don't need to be Spanish to play guitar do I?
2017/11/03 18:35:42
jamesg1213
I can think of a few bluesbaggers who should have stuck with what they know.
2017/11/03 20:25:44
jackson white
There are some who would claim the entire Garth Brooks catalog qualifies for such distinction. 
2017/11/03 20:52:47
mumpcake
eph221
The democratization of the music market makes all those narratives (and poly ticks) moot. You can be whatever you want to be with authenticity.  I don't need to be Spanish to play guitar do I?



The thing about countrybagging is that it is precisely about inauthenticity.  It's about doing something not because you love it, but because you want to cash in.
 
Authenticity comes more from effort and understanding than anything else.  There are a lot of pantheon-level rock players, for example, that think that just because they are talented in that field they can make an authentic blues album.  More often than not, it ends up as an embarrassment.  Or as James said above, "bluesbagging".
 
 
2017/11/03 20:59:11
eph221
Well, the critics be damned.  It is a business, so why wouldn't they make money doing whatever they do?  There are snobs everywhere and frankly, they're not fun to be around.  They suck the oxygen out of the room during performances.  Music is about letting go and letting the muse take over. If you can write a note, you can compose.  Your compositions will be much better, and you'll be happier being *authentic* (maybe.)   And the only way to do that is to study the genre.  I agree, if some new yorker were throwing around Hank Williams name or dropping other names it'd be downright annoying.  In the Jazz world everyone is a freakin pretender and a name dropper.  It don't bother me a bit.  Fake it till ya make it. :D:D
2017/11/03 20:59:23
mumpcake
jackson white
There are some who would claim the entire Garth Brooks catalog qualifies for such distinction.



I'm not a fan, but I would not call him that.
 
I might call him a grungebagger, though:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chris_Gaines
2017/11/03 21:21:53
kennywtelejazz
After enduring the music business's forced steady diet of Divabaggers , Ga Ga Swift  Perry , Shredbaggers fill in the blank , & Beatbangerbaggers
 
Why Should I even Care ?
 
Kenny
2017/11/03 21:52:31
kennywtelejazz
eph221
 I don't need to be Spanish to play guitar do I?




It would certainly help
 
eph221
The democratization of the music market makes all those narratives (and poly ticks) moot. You can be whatever you want to be with authenticity.




Amen I'm gonna give it to you
 
 
Kenny
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account