bapu
Kind of novelty songs to me. Good playing, good voice, witty writing but somehow (for me) it misses the mark.
But, as myolpal says, "that's what makes a horse race".
Bapu, i think that "witty writing" was just part of what made it Canadian. We can't take ourselves seriously, or the audience throws Timbits and moose-droppings at us.
Beepster
Then there's these guys...
Sloan - Good In Everyone (song starts at around 2:11)
Way ahead of their time as far as the full on Indie/Hipster movement IMO (as evidenced by that intro... lol). Of course it's kind of bubble gummy sounding but I always kind of liked them even in the throes of my teenage metal angst.
Anyhoo (and, Sluggo... this happened at the C&D) one of the Sloan doods (pretty sure it was the singer guy) joined forces with my local pub's kind of house band spazzos (who were/are also really friggen' good/talented/theatrical fellos) and put on a Halloween gig. He was mostly on drums and friggen' KILLED it! The whole band just blazed out on all sorts of weird nostalgia rock with kiss makeup (and a couple covers), gorrilla masks, lights/smoke (in a tiny little pub with a TINY little "stage" if you could even call it that).
Great time and of course everyone wanted me to meet the guy which I think might have been kind of awkward for both of us but he was pretty cool and you could tell he just LOVED playing music.
I never got into Sloan, for some reason. I know a couple of them were big fans of a band i used to play in. They'd come to all our local shows, stand in the back (like every other MF on Queen St!), and listen. I met them, but could never remember what their names were or which instrument they played.
I can't believe i was THAT dismissive...