2012/09/29 20:29:37
marcus3
Can I tap my foot and keep time? I hear mostly about sense of time. Which I got real good though I think to much some times haha. 
 
Anyway I use to use metronome but got very mild cp in my legs so mild nobody can tell. Which is good sense there people got worse.
 
And I feel taping my foot and keeping beat in my head will do same as metronme. Correct?
I'm able tap my foot to classical music keeping to the beat.
Plus will help my muscles in my legs stay moving.
 
I'm playing piano plan on posting some my work up soon. Hope this week.
 
thanks
2012/09/29 20:34:56
The Maillard Reaction

Yes you can.

One thing I have done in the past is tap on a simple midi foot pedal trigger and actually record the midi beats.

Then you can use those beats to map the tempo.

You can also do this with a microphone down near your foot, and then use Audio Snap to map the tempo. You don't need a fancy microphone to do this.

best regards,
mike
2012/09/29 20:38:08
Jeff Evans
I think you can do whatever it takes to improve your time. One thing I have found as a drummer is counting aloud while playing can improve your time no end. Even counting only on beats 1 and 3 for example will still improve your time.

Maybe try counting as you play piano at least in practice mode. It is like your counting seems to be locked  to some internal clock which is amazingly accurate and all you have to do is make your playing fall in time with that.
2012/09/29 21:17:14
Rus W
Yeah, lots of aural exercises can help keep time. In fact, this is how many children are taught. (ie: Clapping, Tapping, Snapping, etc.) Even the environment can help.

Look at the second hand on a face clock or when your alarm goes off on a digital clock or watch. They have rhythmic patterns.

And I bet this happens (I've experienced it lots) Have you ever ridden in the car and activated the turn signal or seen the headlights or tail-lights blink where they appear to be doing so rhythmically only to go off-beat later? That's more of a psychological/neural phenomenon, but quite common.

Or say you're hear a song on the radio, and the drum parts (kick/snare/hat) sync up to whatever you're looking at, (the car in front of you; the store sign the blinks off to the side).

But like Beags said: Try to internalize the clock. However, you'll get into the "Mechanical vs. Free" (Rule vs. Feeling/Uniformed/Loose) and dare I say: "Real vs. Fake" debates.

Learning in strict time/tempo is where you should start, then gradually proceed to go off-kilter.

Once you get good enough at it, when listening to songs, you'll start to realize how off-beat they are. It's the illusion of them being on beat, that makes them sound good.

I know you probably talking along the lines of performing, but this works very well when composing.

Also, doing such exercises will help you count when there is absolutely no concrete rhythm (ie: drum beat). This will be hard at first, but it helps you to not use an aural crutch (ie: metronome). Not using a crutch serves you better; however, use it until you get to that point.
2012/09/29 21:29:08
RobertB
What these guys wrote.
Especially this:
"It is like your counting seems to be locked  to some internal clock which is amazingly accurate and all you have to do is make your playing fall in time with that. "
Back when I used to jam regularly with some friends, one of them mentioned that he would just watch my left foot.
Not only was the timing there, but apparently I would telegraph my intentions, and depending on how that foot moved, they knew where I was going, and they could anticipate changes.
So yeah, tap that foot.
2012/09/29 22:08:06
marcus3
Lot great response thanks. I have metronome but decide go way from that. 
I keep better rhythm with my foot and last night watch guy on youtube use Synthogy piano recording into
logic he didn't have metronome but kept on time and yes I have seen that in a car.
I have notice stuff off especially watching live performance is easier to tell. Lot times when I play I don't use metronome just play. If it classical piece I play by ear by the tempo the performer was playing

To me sounds like timing comes by feeling the music your playing. Honestly think metronome is more distracting than using your foot or head. And don't plan on using one for recording. 
2012/09/30 04:18:54
Danny Danzi
Everything you got advice wise is spot on in my opinion. The only thing to be careful of...is if you are mic'ing something up. The last thing you want to appear on a track of vocals or acoustic guitar or whatever, is a constant foot tap that bled through your mic. So though I'm all for tapping, there are certain instances where you want to be careful.

If you could get used to bobbing your head instead of tapping, that would be the better method especially if you are mic'ing instruments. :) Good luck!

-Danny
2012/09/30 08:57:45
Guitarhacker
Foot tapping and sense of time.... interesting topic. 

If you are a drummer..... forget that... drummers always speed up so that never works...


Seriously.... if you want to test your ability to keep time.... put a song on with a good strong beat on a CD or something..... then tap along...get the sense of the time... NOW.... have a friend turn the volume to zero and keep tapping to the clock in your head. Sing along to the words.... but know where you are in the song. After a minute or so, your friend should turn the volume back up. Are you on the same beat and word with the song? Are you close...say with in a beat or less? Or...are you way off?   This will give you a pretty quick idea as to how good your sense of timing really is. 

Most musicians will tap a foot or bob a head to keep time even when a strong beat is evident in the music.

I tend to vary between 3 methods and sometimes have 2 or more going at the same time.  One I tend to use a lot and it provides a strong beat sense but can be quiet is the heel tap. The heel and toe tap can be done silently especially on carpet. Or...take off your shoes and play barefoot. Be careful of the barefoot thing if it's an electric guitar and you are outside on the ground. 

Try tapping to a metronome. With practice you can develop a better sense of tempo so that when you play without one you don't start out slow and end up sprinting. 
2012/09/30 09:09:11
The Maillard Reaction

from: http://www.flatt-and-scruggs.com/earlbio.html


"According to Larry Perkins in a 1990 interview at IBMA, the Scruggs brothers, Earl and Horace, developed their timing by starting a song then walking around the house and meeting at the point of origin. They did this on their songs until they consistently were in time with each other after their walk."



:-)



2012/09/30 09:35:38
trimph1
My diabetes actually got better after I lost a lot of weight due to certain treatments but I did start doing drumming exercises using a simple MIDI trigger device....they do the trick here..and, as well, helps improve my timing...
© 2025 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account