• Techniques
  • Help me analyzing chords in this song: This never happened before (McCartney) (p.5)
2012/07/02 00:30:09
Beepster
No, I take full blame. Now I feel obliged to analyze the song properly... but I'm hungry and tired so I'll do it another day.
2012/07/02 00:58:36
Rus W
^ So, I did help, eh? And I supposed you were tired then. Happens to all of us.
2012/07/02 01:14:14
Beepster
Might give it a whack tomorrow.
2012/07/04 14:44:07
jsaras
The verse is in E major, but he made the IV chord, (normally an A major chord), into a minor chord (A minor).  It's an extremely common device.  

Note that the melody that he sings on the A minor chord, you could indeed play the IV major chord (A major).  You could also try some other "A chords as well; A7, A7sus4, A sus4.  The technique is called "modal interchange".  Other substitute chords you can try in that spot are D7, F#mi7b5, F major7, D minor9, Bb maj7b5 (those were worked out through the overtone series...check out my buddy Helmholtz). The bridge is a ii-V-I progression in the key of G major (Ami-D7-G).  Eventually he throws in the E7 chord, which is a fifth above the following chord which starts the verse (A minor); so he's set up a "secondary dominant" into the Ami chord, a type of V7-i progression.




© 2025 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account