• Hardware
  • why did you pick an iPad vs. android or vice versa ? (p.2)
2017/08/20 22:40:50
tlw
iPad - smooth running, just gets on with it. Good, easy to use operating system. OS updates direct from Apple so no worries about obtaining them - some android users with phone contracts don't get updates to the OS because the phone company won't supply them.

Huge range of apps, some very good, many absolute rubbish but that't the same for all tablet OSs. One advantage of the Apple Store approach, where you can only install apps from there, is that it makes it much harder for the malicious to distribute malware.

Also integrates very well indeed with Macs (at last). We use Macs as the only computers now (tried Win10 and hated it), if you're going to be using Windows you'll lose some functionality but I don't know if Windows tablets can work with PCs in the same kind of way.

The hardware is very resiliant, I've given an original iPad Air a huge amount of use since I bought it when they first came out and it's still going strong. I recently got a 9,3" Pro and for most people's computer usage I suspect it would suffice on its own. Noticably quicker than the Air mk 1 as well. Retina screens are superb displays as well. The Apple pencil thing is expensive, but if you're into photography or artwork is really usefull. Add a third party app and it turns the iPad into a very serious graphics tablet.

Downsides. iTunes is necessary, but it's nothing like as bad as many say. Behaves itself well on the whole and isn't a bad media player at all. You don't even strictly speaking need it, but it's useful for local backups of the iPad and getting media and data on and off the iPad. Just make sure the first thing you do with iTunes is go into the preferences and ensure it's not busily moving all your media files, including recordings, to its own library. :-/

Once in a while iPads get confused, a hard reboot, or if that doesn't restore sanity returning them to original factory settings and reloading your stuff is simple, so long as you have a backup.

Siri. Probably better than Cortana, but as far as I'm concerned both are best terminated with extreme prejudice. Unlike Cortana, once switched off Siri stays off.

iCloud. We only use it for syncing a limited amount of data between tablet/phone/Mac. Photos, music and everything else we store locally.

And don't forget your itunes account/Apple user id and password. The stories of bricked iOS devices following major OS updates almost all boiled down to "it asked me for my account password before loading all my personal stuff and I can't remember it".
2017/08/20 23:34:31
Jeff Evans
Another thing too and that is if you also happen to own an iMac and an iPhone the level of integration for the iPad with these other two devices is just excellent and way above anything Windows could hope to achieve. 
2017/08/21 00:21:32
mettelus
I have never had either, but found out that there are a lot of apps available only in IOS. I got to try out a few supporting apps (Studio One Remote in demo mode, apps for a Fretlight I bought as a gift) and was surprised how smooth it ran. Plus it came with GarageBand for free, so can play with it without buying anything.

Not gotten one yet, since I have no real need, but I know a lot of folks personally with one (there is also a wifi only version, so works in range of wifi without a data plan from a provider). I do not know anyone with a Windows tablet (yet).
2017/08/21 10:54:12
Bflat5
Samsung
2017/08/21 14:17:05
AT
Windows actually integrates well between desktop, tablet and phone (yes, I am the last one in the world with one of 'em).  It is the same OS on all of them, you can load the same programs and apps on each of them, and share any info you have put online between the hardware.  I haven't tried to load in SONAR on my phone, but I wouldn't want to do any sound work on it any way, or type a Russian novel on it.  So it works better in theory than practice, but I could ....
2017/08/21 14:40:00
abacab
I only use Windows because I have a ton of Windows only applications.  It's a necessary evil.  Other than that, I really do not like Windows, and that would be my last choice for a tablet OS.
 
I think anything else is an improvement.  Android, iOS, Linux, MacOS, etc ...
 
2017/08/21 14:54:13
Jim Roseberry
While the iPAD is nice for running remote software, remote-recording, some soft-synths (albeit limited in capability), etc... having to use iTunes to simply move data is **royal bass-akwards**  
 
On an Android, if you want to move an audio file, you connect via USB and drag/drop.
Yep... it's that simple.  My data... and I can immediately access it and do what I wish.
 
Want to move an audio file with your iPhone or iPad?  You've got to fire up iTunes.
Is it a "Voice Memo" or "song"?  
Slow and tedious... because Apple wants complete control.
 
If Android had the same level of (music related) support, I'd use Android exclusively.
 
 
2017/08/21 15:10:19
kennywtelejazz
timidi
It's looking like iPads in the lead.
 
I guess I should have mentioned that my main need/want right now is for maps, internet, netflix, travel.
Sorry I didn't mention that.
I hadn't even thought about music apps. go figure:) 
Thanks again.




At some point I would like to get an iPad . My primarily use would be to use it as a portable music software creation center.
 
The uses you have mentioned in your post that I quoted can all be done on a Chromebook ...
I have one and most people that are looking to music tend to knock them .
The funny thing is this thing kicks the pant's out of my Mac's and Win 10 computers .
It gets a 9 hour battery life , 20 second start up time , runs my 2i4 and my yamaha sound cards as class compliant ...
no drivers were needed to be installed and at times I run my monitors w my SC as I would on any of my music computers .
I never had any buffering problems when streaming videos or movies .Always got a decent Wifi signal..
I don't even have to sign in because I can run in guest mode and stay private on the net or local .
Even in guest mode I can hook up an external HD and play music , watch vids , read pdf's and do a bunch of other things offline ....these things have players built in ...One of these day's I may hook up my tv to it since it has the correct slots ...
The only things the Chromebooks are no good for is if you want to create music or make videos from scratch or any of the other things people would use a traditional computer for as a creator VS consumer..
 
I'm not trying to sway you , I'm just mentioning what I have found out after picking one up for peanuts ...
 
all the best,
 
Kenny
 
2017/08/21 15:55:06
Cactus Music
If it's a travel computer,, I just use my iphone.
As said all the cool apps for music are on OS. I also have a older iPad at home and we have one at work too. The one at work is the 2nd gen the one at home is 3rd gen. All have the same up to date OS so other than the processing speed and the camera quality all  3 of these iOS devices I use are identical to learn and use. I find the OS very logical and other than the above mentioned stupid transferring of data issue they are well thought out. Aslo both old iPAds batteries are toast and cannot be easily replaced so it makes them useless for a lot of things. 
 
I have not purchased it yet but I want to try using "on Song" for displaying my lyrics at gigs. I don't see an app like that for Android. 
Right now I use my little Asus  netbook running Power point and it works fine. 
And speaking of netbooks, mine is 10 years old now, running XP I have used it for hundreds of live gigs for playback and now lyrics and it still runs a smooth a silk. I put an SSD drive in it ad it boots up in a whoping 20 sec ( XP remember was over 1 min. I have also taken it traveling with me for internet. It runs 10 hours on a full charge still and the ssd drive improved that too. 
2017/08/21 15:56:17
Slugbaby
I've always been a PC guy.
I would lean towards an Android or MS tablet for price, however a couple of years ago I won an iPad.
I thought about trading it for a non-Apple device, but was too lazy.  After a few days of getting used to it, I love the simplicity and speed.  It's not very upgradeable or repairable, but it would still get my vote now.
 
When my wife went to a conference for work, she bought a $20 cover for it, with a bluetooth keyboard.  Worked like a charm - small, simple, and reliable.
© 2025 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account