• Hardware
  • why did you pick an iPad vs. android or vice versa ? (p.5)
2017/08/25 23:01:46
timidi
Thanks Soens. Ingenuity at it's finest:)
2017/08/26 02:50:13
Starise
Awhile back I loaded a bunch of music apps on my iPad and iPhone. Actually They share the same apps through iCloud. I pay a small amount to have more storage in iCloud because my devices were filling up. One good reason to buy as much memory as you can when buying an apple device.
 
I played with all that stuff for awhile and the whole thing ran out of steam for me. I didn't really have any practical use for music apps on small devices. Sure , it was cool to make music and record with my phone. Play synths and use guitar simms. In the end though, I followed the path of least resistance and went back to a big screen and easier to use tools.
 
The only thing left now is my iPad which I love for basically reading and web searching. I replaced a cracked screen on my iPhone and when it cracked again I decided I would try an android phone. So I have all of these apps hanging in the could I doubt I'll use. Kind of a waste really.
 
If you go with android devices google gets you connected between devices and accounts the same way Apple connects you through their setup. In fact Google might do a better job of that.
 
My android device isn't lacking in anything, doesn't seem the least bit clunky. 
2017/08/26 18:29:25
Zargg
I got an iPad, because I wanted it. Just that simple.
Would I go the same route again?
I have no idea 
2017/08/26 20:38:39
Jeff Evans
An iPad dock really changes things and makes it more professional to use in a studio environment.  Alesis and Focusrite make them.  I picked up a second hand one on eBay.  For a third of the original price, making it attractive.  It is not something that one would normally think about.  It gives you access to Midi and audio IN/OUT via external connectors.  The internal D/A in the iPad is bypassed and that is provided for in the dock.  So when Focusrite is handling that job, it is a different sound.  The iPad is charged of course in the dock too. 
 
I started using it as a synth and it performs very nicely in that area.  Delivering a big quality sound to my synth mixer along with everything else.  A +4 dBu signal mostly and very quiet, on balanced outputs.  It also runs those great remote control apps like the one for Studio One.  And it works great.  Especially for me playing in drum parts and taking control of my studio in another room.  It can mount next to me.
 
Some synths like iOS Synthmaster for example offer large dual X/Y pads and I have become custom to using them.  I found once I got into this I could not go back.  It is very cool to play.  It responds super fast as well.  The trick is to put the iPad and its dock onto a nice stand angled up further.  It sits on my main table and all I have to do is slide it out to play it.  It is the perfect size for being stored away out of sight or pulled forward and used as a controller or synth.  Your moves can recorded, edited and played back.  The pads send midi to the rest of my system via the midi outs.  I have found editing synth sounds also rather quick and easy using the iPad.  Korg MS20 and Polysix are very nice to edit their patches etc.. The whole touch thing here works very nicely.  I have got into editing say an MS20 patch like I did when I owned it.  It encourages you to experiment.  The iPad feels the same.  The GUI's are nice and so sharp and detailed.  You can zoom right into controls on many synth apps.  The whole image looks nicer to me.  Some synth apps look much nicer than their Windows counterparts.  (MS20 is a serious floor shaker and Polysix sounds so close it is almost majestic. Synthmaster sounds ridiculous and now I have added PPG Infinite which is one of the nicest sounding instruments I own in my whole setup!)
 
You can surf the net too and any music you may be listening too is coming out sounding rather spectacular to say the least.  (For music production tutorials this is a must!) It is great having it close to your main machine's screen as well.  And if that is an iMac (as I have Studio One installed and running on two computers), then it is even more powerful. It is also handy to have around as you can run any tutorials or leaning tools on the iPad, hear it all in high fidelity but have your main machine totally free to follow what is going on. 
 
There are new apps now too like a recent one that turns the iPad into a super keyboard command controller and overall control surface for a host of DAW's including mine.  In my case it can sit directly above my QWERTY keyboard and next to a Presonus Faderport which is also an amazing tool to have in close proximity to the iPad. 
 
Out and away from the studio all I have to do is add a small keyboard, phones, a mic and you can record direct to DI inputs too. It's a full blown studio outside on location.  I take this away on holidays sometimes at the ready just in case I get an idea.  The dock can be powered from a solar panel too and it will power the mentioned devices and run for hours.  You can plug in two mics or a stereo mic capturing quality sound effects atmospheric and foley like sounds too.  Far easier too use and see than a tiny Zoom for example.  Have they ever made a pro audio dock for a Windows tablet?
2017/08/27 09:26:12
Zargg
I forgot.
I've used my iPad as a Control Surface when using my laptop, via rtpMIDI and AC-7 core HD.
Really useful 
2017/08/29 01:33:14
kitekrazy1
I really wanted Garage Band so I paid $400 and got an iPad with it.  That is the most I ever paid for a DAW.
2017/09/03 20:35:59
timidi
So, I've had the iPad ($329) a few days and just got a Samsung galaxy s2 ($349).  I'll return one in a few days.
https://www.bestbuy.com/site/apple-ipad-latest-model-with-wifi-32gb-space-gray/4907703.p?skuId=4907703
https://www.amazon.com/Samsung-Galaxy-Tablet-Black-SM-T813NZKEXAR/dp/B01DXVKHH8
 
screen res on the iPad does seem a bit better.
don't really like that I don't have any control over my stuff with the ipad. However, I'm starting to realize that the whole tablet thing is just sort of a novelty that may be fun here and there but...
 
One biggie that I just learned is that the samsung will not charge via USB (computer or car). It has to be plugged in (to the wall).
iPad seems capable of this.
 
I'll try some netflix-ing later on.
 
So far, both seem adequate. iPad is a little flashier however cumbersome in it's complexity.
The samsung is more, Duh that's easy.. The Samsung was $20 more (on sale).
 
Learned about bluetooth tethering today (for internet sharing) which I don't think the iPad will do with my android phone. works great with the samsung tablet. It appears (from web reading) that bluetooth tethering is better than normal hot spotting? Don't really know though.
 
Comparison continues.
2017/09/03 23:51:06
michaelhanson
I'm a PC guy, but I love my iPhone and iPad.  I used Android for years, but when I finally gave in and bought a iPhone, there was no going back.  
 
I use the iPad and an iKlip while playing live;  to display the Chord/ Lyric sheets.  There are several apps out there that give you this ability; infact IK has one of those apps.  We use Planning Center and it works seamlessly.  
 
I have done a little recording with the iPad, using Garage Band.  It seems to be OK for doing a scratch demo.  I use it a lot for lyric writing.  Through the Cloud, Notes, connects with my iPhone, so if I quickly type in lyrics, it automatically changes what is on my iPad as well.  
 
There also are tons of apps for music.  Rhyming apps, guitar chord apps, tuners, Amplitube, just to name a few.  
 
 
2017/09/03 23:56:09
michaelhanson
timidi
 
Learned about bluetooth tethering today (for internet sharing) which I don't think the iPad will do with my android phone. works great with the samsung tablet. It appears (from web reading) that bluetooth tethering is better than normal hot spotting? Don't really know though.
 
Comparison continues.




I tether my iPad from my iPhone all of the time.  It works great and yes, better than hot spot and wifi connections, most of the time.  I believe that it is also safer to tether, when out and about.  
2017/09/04 00:21:21
samson7842
I love the iPad for on the go music making. So simple and intuitive. Admittedly, I haven't used it much because I've been mostly tethered to my apartment because of an injury. So, I just use my Sonar rig. But, it's great as a portable songwriting tool. Which is exactly why I bought it.
© 2025 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account