Yep. listened to 'em both, I found myself liking this one a little more . . . I like the percussive sound that moves around in panning, like you are banging a piece of flexible drain pipe. I think the audio quality in this one is a little better than the other.
Super creative and very original! But for whatever reason, when you do quirky love songs they hold my interest a little longer, just my opinion there. Your vocal has a cool quality to it, and I wonder if you ever thought of doubling it (actually singing it twice as opposed to making a copy) and then adding some nice microshifting or chorus? Just a thought, I bet that would sound pretty ****in' . . . hope I can say that on TV.
cheers,
-Tom
****no I guess I can't. Oh well. :)