Ed, this is really good man! I like everything about it. Solid mix. A few little crits if I may?
Definitely not diggin' the excessive vibrato on the vocal...there's so much it pushes itself out of key. I echo Herb on the Melodyne comment as that could have helped a bit there. Then the singer may have been upset because it would have definitely altered what he's used to.
Back-ups: We have some congestion there that is keeping them from coming out and hitting the way they should. They need a little more sparkle. Turning them up louder in their present form would mask other elements of the mix. A little 8-12k with a tight cue can add a little air to sparkle them up a bit...play with dropping mids from 600-800Hz add some air, compress them a bit more and they should leap into action.
Horns: We gotta get these babies out more. They sound VERY centered and sort of walk over top of things in the center pan field which gives them less impact when they hit. This is just me, but I would have made them hit pan wise on the outside of the ride and the hats...just outside the drum kit and in between the back up vocals. Eq sounded fine on them...they just were fighting too many centered instruments. You got 200 pan positions plus imaging if need be. Always try to use them to your advantage. Impact instruments need a special place to shine that isn't the same spot as a focal point position or a lead vocal. If these were mono you could have HAAS'd them and used an imager or a Sonitus Phase plug to make them a bit more narrow to control where they would hit.
Bub's timing comment: I hear it too. The drums are a little loose in spots...nothing major, but that's what *I* hear.
And...I hated the sna....sike, I absolutely LOVED this snare drum! Finally one I like! LOL! Nice crack, good body, perfect snare for the tune! Well done Ed, Alex and everyone else! Great tune, great mix! Hopefully some of this stuff helps you for next time. :)
-Danny