2017/04/10 03:50:24
bapu
sharke
and they might also have a linguistic element to them as well. 


This is a family friendly website. We'll have none of that sex talk here.
2017/04/10 03:54:01
quantumeffect
bapu
sharke
and they might also have a linguistic element to them as well. 


This is a family friendly website. We'll have none of that sex talk here.


Now that was a cunning reply.
2017/04/10 03:57:16
sharke
Kingpin fans will know what I'm talking about. 

2017/04/10 19:43:37
SoundRegion
craigb
Turn on some type of recording device (even a phone works) then play whatever you want on a piano (along with random stuff).  Go back and listen to the recording and see if there are any "Ooo... THAT has potential!" parts then flesh a few of those out.  The key is to not think about it during the recording process, just let things flow and completely ignore anything that doesn't sound good! 


Yeah done that before only right now the melodies sorta come easy to me. The only thing I'm thinking about is that if they come that easy, they're probably no good and I'm fining it hard to decide what to use.
jamesg1213
Here's a couple that might give you some inspiration;
 



Good choices. thanks.
 
sharke
The Lark Ascending is a good one, loads of great melodies in there. In fact Vaughan Williams' stuff is a treasure trove of amazing melodies, some of them taken from English folk music.
 
To me one mark of a good melody is its whistleability. The first melody in "English Folk Song Suite" by Vaughan Williams is a fine example. It has every good hallmark of a great melody and I whistle it all the time. Another great trove of melodies is Holst's "Jupiter" from The Planets. 
 
And you can't discuss melody without mentioning Mussorgsky's "Pictures At An Exhibition." 
 
I think good melodies have a pleasing element of symmetry in them, and they might also have a linguistic element to them as well. 


Thanks for the suggestion. Jupiter is a perfect example of what I'm looking for. Very beautiful ! Not too familiar with the british composers.


2017/04/10 23:30:50
Bhav
Maple Leaf and Pineapple rags are the most perfect melodies to my ears.
2017/04/11 13:51:25
Mesh
 
 

2017/04/12 03:48:56
bitflipper
Examples of perfect melodies:
Greensleeves
Pachelbel's Canon
Ave Maria
How do I know they're perfect? People are still humming them after 300 hundred years.
2017/04/12 09:35:07
Bhav
Oh Greensleeves is wonderful. 
2017/04/12 09:51:41
synkrotron
Bhav
Oh Greensleeves is wonderful. 




I tend to agree but, after reading Mr Townsend's post I had to listen to a bit of Meshuggah to get Greensleeves out of my head.
 
And it's there again now 
2017/04/12 17:40:59
eph221
bitflipper
Examples of perfect melodies:
Greensleeves
Pachelbel's Canon
Ave Maria
How do I know they're perfect? People are still humming them after 300 hundred years.




 
Anonymous...the most prolific composer ever!
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account