• SONAR
  • X3 Take Lanes Mystery - Am I Doing This Correctly?
2014/08/13 10:13:50
SteveStrummerUK
 
Hi guys, can anyone tell me if this is expected behaviour, or if I'm missing something here.
 
When I perform Bounce To Clip(s) on a track with multiple Track Lanes, SONAR correctly creates a single clip.
 
However, I'm still left with all the empty 'redundant' Take Lanes after the bounce.
 
Is this what should happen, or, as I would have assumed, should all the empty Track Lanes automatically be deleted in the process?
 
Here's my method (referencing the animated gif below) so you can see more easily where I'm going wrong:
  1. Track expanded to show Take Lanes
  2. I select the track
  3. I right click and select Bounce To Clip(s)
  4. Empty Take Lanes are not removed from the track

 
 
Thanks in advance of any help
2014/08/13 14:13:31
stevec
I think this question had come up before and I don't think the empty lanes are supposed to be automatically deleted, though I really don't recall why.
 
That said, it would be convenient to have the "delete empty lanes" command wired into the bounce command, at least as an option.
 
2014/08/13 14:20:09
Anderton
stevec
It would be convenient to have the "delete empty lanes" command wired into the bounce command, at least as an option.

 
Until then, right-click on the Composite (parent) track and choose "Remove Empty Take Lanes."
2014/08/13 15:19:22
SteveStrummerUK
 
Steve, Craig - many thanks for your replies, and for the clarification.
 
I'd already knew about Remove Empty Take Lanes, I just couldn't understand why SONAR doesn't automatically remove any empty lanes during the bounce. Try as I might, I can't think of a single good reason for leaving them there 
 
 
 
 
 
2014/08/13 15:43:16
ETPayton
In case you change your mind?
2014/08/13 16:17:33
Anderton
SteveStrummerUK
 
Steve, Craig - many thanks for your replies, and for the clarification.
 
I'd already knew about Remove Empty Take Lanes, I just couldn't understand why SONAR doesn't automatically remove any empty lanes during the bounce. Try as I might, I can't think of a single good reason for leaving them there 

 
If you use lots of Take Lanes as a "sandbox" for recording multiple takes, bounce only some of the clips as an intermediate step, and all empty lanes are removed, you'd need to create more lanes every time you did intermediate bounces. However if you were correlating particular parts to track numbers, you couldn't create lanes with the numbers that were removed. IOW if you had Takes 1-5, Takes 2+4 ended up empty, and you wanted to start a part on a new Take 4, you couldn't. If you create a new Take, it will be numbered Take 6.
 
Of course everyone's workflow is different but I rarely use Take Lanes, do a single bounce, and I'm done.  I end up dragging clips to newly-emptied Lanes, recording into them, and so on. For me, it would be more troublesome to keep having to create new empty lanes every time I bounced than it would be to right-click and delete any remaining ones when I'm done.
2014/08/13 17:58:56
Sanderxpander
I think if your purpose is to create "one take" from a selection of different clips in lanes, the idea is to use "flatten comp", in which case all your lanes will be gone.
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account