Something similar happened to me yesterday...
I had a send on two of my gtr tracks going to a bus with an ambience verb.
I turned off the sends to the bus but I was still getting an ambience verb with my guitar.
Turns out that somehow the sends got duplicated and I actually had two sends on each track feeding the bus (hard to tell how many sends you have going on in track view...)
Once I deleted send number 2, all was well again!
Don't know if I hit a hot key or something or how it happened but I now know to look for that...