Thanks beep, good thoughts all. Indeed these were recorded with no click and hence the difficulty in lining them up with time in cakewalk.
At least the 1" 16 track deck he has is very stable, so the drift between the two files is virtually nonexistent. Lining up the two groups of files using the vocal track as the duplicate/overlapping track seems to work well. It's actually easier to hear if the vocals are in sync than it is a snare drum or guitar. Once in sync the two tracks just meld together and sound like one track.
I have the one file lined up using the manual method I described and the nudge function to get it exact. I can play the two vocal tracks solo'd through the whole song and they don't drift at all. Playing all the tracks and giving them a listen sounds pretty much spot on.
For the next file I'm going to use your suggestion as that seems to be a lot more efficient way of doing it. From your post.. "turn on Transients, set the now time to line up with a specific transient (one that appears in both tracks). Then insert a Snap Offset marker on one at the Now Time and line it up to a point on the grid. Then do the same thing to the other track."
It's a cool project and is going to be fun.
Also you asked about my experience with cakewalk. I've had an on again, off again experience with cakewalk. I used it years ago as a midi recorder to sync to a tape deck with SMPTE. We recorded all the synths and a few other things on the computer via midi and all the other stuff on tape. We didn't really use a lot of the functions, just burned a sync track on tape and used it to extend the tracks of our tape deck.
Then work got in the way and we stopped recording for a while. Now we're back into it and I'm just now learning all the new stuff.
One thing that's always been a problem for me is that all the tinkering with computers tends to completely zap your creative side.. Therefore we have mostly used it sort of like an old fashioned tape deck, turn it on an PLAY! If things are out of time or don't sound right, don't fix it on the computer, PLAY IT AGAIN! hahaha. It's much more enjoyable to play another take than it is to get all balled up in the computer.
I also think the time changes and drifting around of live music is much more pleasing to me than stuffy things that are sync'd perfectly to a click track. As long as it's with good musicians and within reason. So I've not played around with all this sync stuff too much in the past.
I also don't do this for a living, otherwise I would have to learn how to deal with what other people want to do. Myself and a few long time friends write songs and play music. We now live in different parts of the country, so we're learning how to do this remotely using cakewalk.