Update: After inspecting it closer, the only thing I changed the last time I used it was that I replaced and instance of Amplitube with Revalver. When I disabled the Revalver plug, and saved, it re-opened fine. It wasn't UAD--it was Revalver! Once I opened it, I enabled the Revalver plug, froze the track, and everything seems fine now.
It's funny how one plugin might make others seem like they're the culprit.