• SONAR
  • Feature Request: "Hide Take" buttons on lanes and built in Take Manager on tracks. Yes? (p.2)
2014/05/12 14:43:27
stevec
Nice to see you around again, Beeps.   
 
2014/05/12 20:47:02
icontakt
Vastman
Tak... maybe the "take manager" button could go "green" or some other color if there were hidden takes...

 
Beepster
I was considering your comment last night and I think what I would like is for the on track "Lane Manager" button (that would open the lane manager for the track) to have a number on it reflecting how many lanes are currently hidden.

 
Good ideas. Now, I'm actually giving this FR a big +1 but only because of one reason. Currently, even if you mute the clip or mute the lane itself, the clip muted still appears in the main track when lanes are collapsed. This isn't good if you want to keep idea clips or alternative takes in the same track for later use (until then you don't want to see them in the main track, do you?). Also, I sometimes encounter a strange bug where I select a clip in the main track (with lanes collapsed) but it actually selects a muted clip hidden behind it. So, if the "Hide Take" feature is implemented, I'm sure clips in hidden lanes will NOT show up in the main track at all. That would really be helpful.
2014/05/13 10:59:18
Beepster
stevec
Nice to see you around again, Beeps.   
 




Thanks. It's good to be back and working on music type stuff again. It was a very unproductive winter for me.
 
Jlien X
Vastman
Tak... maybe the "take manager" button could go "green" or some other color if there were hidden takes...

 
Beepster
I was considering your comment last night and I think what I would like is for the on track "Lane Manager" button (that would open the lane manager for the track) to have a number on it reflecting how many lanes are currently hidden.

 
Good ideas. Now, I'm actually giving this FR a big +1 but only because of one reason. Currently, even if you mute the clip or mute the lane itself, the clip muted still appears in the main track when lanes are collapsed. This isn't good if you want to keep idea clips or alternative takes in the same track for later use (until then you don't want to see them in the main track, do you?). Also, I sometimes encounter a strange bug where I select a clip in the main track (with lanes collapsed) but it actually selects a muted clip hidden behind it. So, if the "Hide Take" feature is implemented, I'm sure clips in hidden lanes will NOT show up in the main track at all. That would really be helpful.




Maybe I'll send it off this afternoon. That last part about muted clips showing up in the parent track is weird. I haven't really seen that behavior. I thought if a range on the timeline was silent but had muted material (clip mute) that that section of the parent track remained blank. I'll check that out later.
 
As far as muted clips being drawn to the surface when working with the parent track... well that's gotta be a bug or something. Kind of weird but it reminds me almost of how my old DAW (and I'll mention it just for the purpose of this convo... Nuendo2) handled takes. Everything would track into the same trackspace and whatever take was "On Top" was what was audible/editable. So the last clip recorded would automatically go on top and muted everything recorded earlier. You accessed previous takes by right clicking on on the track/clip area and a numbered list popped up. Then you selected from that list to bring older takes to the top which changed the list priority. The clip that was previously on top now goes down to number two and number two goes to number three, etc. That way if you had let's say the beginning half of a song take that was good but the ending was bad and another where the ending was good but the beginning was bad or you just punched in then you would make sure those two takes were on top and you'd slip edit the clips to the right spot. It was a pretty cool system and personally I would mind seeing something like that for editing in the parent track so you could edit/audition with the Take Lanes closed. This would go well with the Flatten Comp feature. You could put together a few versions of the entire song using Flatten Comp, close the Take Lanes to save screenspace then cycle through your takes to see which you like best or mix and match with slip editing. That with a Hide Takes function you could have a setting to make it so only the flattened versions are shown (or all if you want) and bingo bango... old school but intuitive and minimalistic editing AND the fancy shmancy Take Lanes comping method for more intricate work.
 
But that's just dreaming right now. The Hide functions I mentioned earlier would be mmore than enough to make this old Beep happy.
 
Cheers.
12
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account