A audio interface with good pre amps like the Scarlett series, and any good mike will give you all you need. It's tooo bad you can't use the Sampson. It will cost you another $100-$200 to replace it.
Your mike? Without comparing it to other mikes I cannot say but my guess is it sounds just fine. There are many, many mikes on the market, too many. And depending on what your looking for, most will sound perfectly fine if your level of expectations is in the lower end of the scale. Nothing wrong with that, this is just a hobby for most of us.
The good old SM 57. If I owned just one mike, this would be it. A Beta 57 might be better.
For my Vocals I'm using a old, old Audio Technica mike that looks like a 58. The number wore off 20 years ago. But I like what my voice sounds like both live and in the studio with this mike. It was only $120 back when. So finding your favorite mike is a personal thing. If you can try as many as possible.
It's worth a mention that a work around for you is to not use Sonar at all. Sonar is the worlds pickiest DAW when it comes to drivers. Your mike will work fine with programs like Audacity.
What some folks do is record into Audacity and import those tracks into Sonar to mix. Clunky and not perfect, but FREE>