• SONAR
  • Controlling Sonar from 2nd laptop? (p.2)
2014/03/08 09:27:20
gustabo
Unfortunately Remote Desktop (the server portion) doesn't come with any Win 7 or 8 Home edition, only pro or beyond. $100 upgrade to a pro version of Win is ridiculous is all you're after is remote capabilities so I purchased RAdmin for my purposes and it which works flawlessly. There is a 30 day free trial available.
2014/03/08 15:26:42
Ruben
I have a project that I need to overdub with acoustic guitar, which requires me to be musician and engineer. But I need to record the guitar in another room and I've been investigating remote access options, so this thread comes at an opportune time for me.
 
First, I set up TouchDAW for my Droid Incredible. Simple start/stop/record functions work very well with fast response. Plus faders for 8 tracks. I had to install rtpMIDI on my DAW but once I got it configured it worked very well. If all you need is remote access to the transport functions TouchDAW works very nicely.
 
However, like the OP, I decided that it would be better if I could see my DAW screen (to adjust levels) so I tested three options to use my laptop as a remote - AirDisplay, VNC and Windows Remote Desktop (RDP).
 
First I installed the demo version of AirDisplay, and as I noted in my post above, lots of screen lag - in fact, really annoying screen lag. Once you have the connection, you will need to have the laptop at your DAW so you can adjust the desired  application windows on the second screen (laptop). Screen drawing is poor - take a close look at the AirDisplay image below and check out the text - lots of broken text which could make smaller text difficult to read. But the deal breaker for me was the screen lag - sometimes when trying to move the mouse arrow, it would just disappear and I'd have to wait for it to appear again. Or I'd click "play" and it wouldn't start, so I would click "play" again, but then it would start from the first click then pause because of the second click. If this was the only option available you could at least get it to remotely start and stop your DAW, but with better options there is no need to use AirDisplay, even less because it costs $20. Use your $20 to buy Nectar and use VNC or RDP for remote access.
 
VNC means "virtual network computing" and it is a way to remotely access any other computer that supports VNC. So you could use your Mac or Linux laptop to control your Windows DAW, or vice versa. There are several free VNC programs (search the interwebs) and I used TightVNC on both my Windows 8.1 DAW and my Win7 laptop. VNC gives you full control of the remote desktop and the screen lag is much lower than with AirDisplay - in fact for me it was almost imperceptible. And the advantage over TouchDAW is that you can see meters (to adjust levels, which I'll need for overdubbing guitar). VNC is a good working, free option.
 
Next I tried Window Remote Desktop (RDP). RDP is very handy when working on a Windows network with multiple servers and workstations and is free in some versions of Windows - I thought it was included in all versions of Windows, but apparently that's not true. Third-party implementations of RDP servers and clients are available for Mac OS and Linux, many of them free. If you have it, you will need to allow Remote Desktop connections on your DAW to make the connection. It connects easily and has almost no screen lag. Buttons clicked work immediately, windows dragged move cleanly. It gives the user a full view of the remote desktop. Out of the three options tested, RDP works the best.
 
RDP is also the least resource-intensive of these three programs. In the photos below are views of the task manager using each program. In each set, the task manager image on the left is my DAW without any remote connections, with Sonar X2 open. The task manager image on the right is the view with each particular remote app connected. So in the first photo, the task manager on the left is with no remote access, and the view on the right is my DAW connected to AirDisplay. The second photo is no remote access (left) and connected with TightVNC (right). The third photo is no remote access (left) and connected with RDP (right). As you can see, AirDisplay uses the most CPU resources, with the VNC connection using just a bit lower, and lastly the RDP connection using noticeably fewer resources still.
 
Windows 8 DAW Task Manager without/with AirDisplay

 
Windows 8 DAW Task Manager without/with VNC connection

 
Windows 8 DAW Task Manager without/with RDP

 
 
 
So according to these results, using RDP would result in the best quality with the lowest resource impact, followed by VNC, with AirDisplay being the lowest quality connection and using the most resources of the three.
 
FYI, TouchDAW used about the same CPU resources as RDP, so if I just simply and quickly need to access my DAW's transport, I'll probably use TouchDAW - nice access, small remote unit (Driod phone). But if I need to set levels or otherwise see the DAW screen I'll be using RDP for remote access. HTH.
2014/03/08 17:21:02
sharke
Great info, thanks! I have a new rig on order from Jim Roseberry and once it's set up I will be delving into all of this. My goal is to have the console on the touchscreen and keep my two monitors for tracking/arrangement and plugin windows.
2014/03/08 18:14:34
Sanderxpander
Huh, to be honest, although I recommended it I'm surprised to hear such good results using Windows RDP. It is obviously the simplest option, with the most complete control (vs TouchDAW and the like) but in the past when I've used it it has always been just slightly laggy, so I thought it may not work if you need the control to be very immediate (where eg TouchDAW would excel). Glad to hear it's working so well.

Come to think of it, when I used it it was to admin an old ass Celeron based home server so perhaps that's why it is laggy. I hadn't considered it's not available in Home editions, I've always used Pro or Ultimate for this and other networking bits and bobs included. May give this another go!
2014/03/09 11:56:03
Ruben
Sanderxpander
Huh, to be honest, although I recommended it I'm surprised to hear such good results using Windows RDP.



Honestly, before I started the comparisons, I felt the same way. I assumed that RDP would have a lot of overhead and that VNC would be the most efficient, so I was surprised with the results.
 
I'm glad I did the tests, though, because I would have just gone with VNC and not even considered RDP.
2014/03/09 14:23:39
bapu
jkleban
I use this for tracking sessions where I need to be both the musician and the engineer.  Touch the record button and off we go... bad take, no problem, CNTL Z, hit record again... all from the comfort of my guitar playing bar stool in another room from my DAW.

Ok, so you move into another room (away from the noise of your DAW, presumably) to have a (noise generating) computer sitting near you while recording?
 
Then again, maybe there is another reason?
2014/03/09 17:18:01
thebiglongy
Use Teamviewer :) Simple and easy to set up. Gives you control  over your pc and you can see and in most cases even hear what is being played.
2014/03/09 20:06:59
jimkleban
sharke
Great info, thanks! I have a new rig on order from Jim Roseberry and once it's set up I will be delving into all of this. My goal is to have the console on the touchscreen and keep my two monitors for tracking/arrangement and plugin windows.



Exactly my setup rig... two touchscreen monitors at the mixing desk and my SURFACE RT in the tracking room.  Works great. I know I have WIN 8 but didn't think I had an advanced edition, but the RDT was already available. Also, it was already an APP installed on my Surface RT.
2014/03/09 20:20:52
Ruben
thebiglongy
Use Teamviewer :) 



TeamViewer is a bit different, much more of a feature set actually, than simple remote desktop - its features are like a combination of VNC and RDP. With TeamViewer, in addition to remote desktop control, you can set up Internet-based meetings, transfer files, and even play sounds from the host computer on the remote computer. It also has other features that require add-on modules. TeamViewer is promoted as an alternative to remote assistance apps like LogMeIn. It is available for both Windows and Mac, so you could control your Windows DAW from your Mac laptop (there are also versions for the iPad). It is offered free for private use.
 
TeamViewer has a very quick screen response, as good as VNC IMO, and the screen looks sharp (unlike AirDisplay) so it's good those regards. But there are a couple of downsides to TeamViewer - 1) it uses more resources than RDP (although not as much as VNC). It installs modules for its features, and the more features, the more modules (and the more services running in the background).
 
CPU Usage - base 2.30:
RDP:  increase to 2.38
TeamViewer:  increase to 2.57
VNC:  increase to  2.73


But the second issue with TeamViewer is that it requires an Internet connection. Not just a local network connection - TeamViewer phones home, so it needs an Internet connection and will not connect to remote desktops without it. Aside from many users who don't allow their DAW's on the Internet, this also raises the issue is privacy - what is being reported back to TeamViewer and are they tracking your usage.
 
For me, I'm going to stick with RDP.
2014/03/10 05:06:29
Rob from Sydney
I had a go at this a while ago (and didn't get far at the time); I've got a windows 7 desktop machine with a windows 7 slate tablet that's a bit underpowered now but would be a great control surface, nice big screen.  While I could get an android tablet and put TouchDAW on it, it seems annoying to have to buy an extra device...
 
I had tried VNC at the time, lag was horrible and not worth bothering.  I think a different implementation of VNC (real vs tight, etc) was suggested, but I didn't get back to trying this.  And it was a bit painful trying to get the right window, or portion of, displayed on the VNC screen.  I usually run the Console (and/or whole multidock) on a second monitor.
 
I suspect RDP will be better performance (as tested above by Ruben) - it's certainly my past experience of it vs VNC. But again I'm not sure if it will be a bit tricky to set it up to share the console window off to the side.
 
Meanwhile, I thought I'd try and see what was around equivalent to TouchDAW that could work on Windows (7 in my case - so not Windows 8 RT for anyone following along with an RT tablet).  First thought was the BlueCat Remote Control, tried to demo it on the local computer but realised it would be ok to setup for a few MIDI-learn type functions but not a control surface, or at least I couldn't figure out how to.  So the current plan is to build something with CTRLR (I can't post links yet, but ctrlr.org is the one) to mimic the console view, and map its MIDI messages to a "Generic" Control Surface.  If you get that far, the Motu Mixer7s panel on that site is the kind of thing I've got in mind.  This can then run on the tablet, with rtpMidi to send it across to the main PC, again basically like TouchDAW.
 
Right now I've started mapping the MIDI messages to an AKAI MPK49 - first in the preset list from the generic surface and looks easy enough to clone.  Volume and pan for the first two channels work ok, so I think this will work alright at least for a one-way link; would like to make the mute, solo buttons work next.  I guess an Edirol PCR is another obvious choice to emulate. 
 
Thinking that if it could be remapped to Mackie or VS700 messages, then it might allow two-way messages and move the faders on screen? This might be easier now with the source code to work out which message is hooked up to what controls...  But I'll leave this for a later exercise once it all works, and not familiar enough with Mackie to know how its protocol works.
 
Won't get near this again for 2-3 weeks but will try and spend a day to see if it gets off the ground and works well enough ... i'll let you know if so!  And meanwhile I'll try give RDP another go and see if it have more success there.
 
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account