CakeAlexS
Markyzo I see Sonar Producer X1d, X2a, X3c 64 bit in your footer so just wanted to check if you were running X3D (and done the thing that should not be mentioned ever).
 
Cheers..

*sigh* Alex....you!!! (yes I have installed Driver boost, have the latest bios, reset my soul etc etc  )

No I am not running X3d because of video issues. But there is nothing in X3D that would address this over X3c *I think*, if there is I am caught between a rock and a hard place.

jkleban
I use KONTAKT a lot with multiple instances as well and can't say that I have ever experienced issues as you have outlined.  The ZERO'ed data however, has been caused by a MIDI setting preferences that ZERO controller data at project start (or something like that) that I use to make sure all MODULATION and other settings get reset at the start of a song... perhaps this is ZEROing out the VOLUME or EXP cc's you may be using to control the output gain of KONTAKT tracks?
 
No idea on the rest of your trials but sounds real ugly to me.
 
Jim

Jim, yeah word....first point of call was zero controllers, so thanks anyway good wise Sir but am all over that like a tramp on chips.

I honestly think theres some weird rubbish with NI and Sonar. *massive sigh*

Usually I can find a workaround that I dont bore people with but the point of my post is to gather forces in fellow NI users that *may* have experienced said issues/gremlins so we can all gang up on Sonar and NI (and then make it work) 

Ok well that establishes something, I have Komplete and  X3D, I'm not experiencing this with Kontakt but then I'm not running X3D. Maybe X3C users could chirp in.
 
>  But there is nothing in X3D that would address this over X3c *I think*,
 
That really is hard to tell I would say. There were plenty of fixes in X3D that could effect/change Kontakt functionality. So that's my recommendation... until I read this:
 
> No I am not running X3d because of video issues.
 
Then again I get you here, there is that one bug.
 
Cheers...

markyzno

Sanderxpander
Hasn't happened to me yet but I don't use Spitfire or Cinebrass, perhaps that makes a difference. Can you give specific steps to reproduce or is it one of those voodoo "now that everyone's looking it does work" issues?

Its hard to reproduce really....

Lets say I record a violin part in Spitfire Solo via Kontakt 5, in the session the keyswitches respond and record fine, any automation I record is fine.....I close the session, reopen it and its all gone, so basically I lose any kind of human shaping in the part and get very harsh transitional strings.....The thing thats puzzling me is there is nothing in event viewer in Sonar...It seems that somehow Sonar and Kontakt refuse to play ball somehow in recalling key human touches via keyswitches, volume controls, modulation wheel etc etc...Let me stress, If I record automation in Sonar its fine (which doesnt actually help), it just seems that Kontakt and Sonar arent playing ball properly....

I did bring up a kind of issue like this with Guitar Rig 5 and freezing and unfreezing and losing presets.... with my problem seeking brain I am kinda of assuming that all these issues are related.

So in essence, Sonar is fine at recording its own in house automation, but when relating to NI Kontakt 5 and *some* instruments, it certainly does not. Now, as my DAW I expect it to, and NI, as my instrument handler I expect it to do the bloody same! Otherwise whats the point in composing with these tools?

Again, today, when sound designing I was trying to automate a volume on a track from a Kontakt instrument and no matter what every time I hit space to play it resets everything unless the automation is recorded on Sonar itself rather than the plug in.

Something is getting lost in translation it seems.

I am still trying to play catch up on the situation.  Are the articulations showing up in Event Viewer when you record?
 
 
 
Bob Bone
 

CakeAlexS
Ok well that establishes something, I have Komplete and  X3D, I'm not experiencing this with Kontakt but then I'm not running X3D. Maybe X3C users could chirp in.
 
>  But there is nothing in X3D that would address this over X3c *I think*,
 
That really is hard to tell I would say. There were plenty of fixes in X3D that could effect/change Kontakt functionality. So that's my recommendation... until I read this:
 
> No I am not running X3d because of video issues.
 
Then again I get you here, there is that one bug.
 
Cheers...

Alex ....Dude!!!  I dont think its got anything to do with X3c to D etc from what I have read in the documentation.

robert_e_bone

markyzno

Sanderxpander
Hasn't happened to me yet but I don't use Spitfire or Cinebrass, perhaps that makes a difference. Can you give specific steps to reproduce or is it one of those voodoo "now that everyone's looking it does work" issues?

Its hard to reproduce really....

Lets say I record a violin part in Spitfire Solo via Kontakt 5, in the session the keyswitches respond and record fine, any automation I record is fine.....I close the session, reopen it and its all gone, so basically I lose any kind of human shaping in the part and get very harsh transitional strings.....The thing thats puzzling me is there is nothing in event viewer in Sonar...It seems that somehow Sonar and Kontakt refuse to play ball somehow in recalling key human touches via keyswitches, volume controls, modulation wheel etc etc...Let me stress, If I record automation in Sonar its fine (which doesnt actually help), it just seems that Kontakt and Sonar arent playing ball properly....

I did bring up a kind of issue like this with Guitar Rig 5 and freezing and unfreezing and losing presets.... with my problem seeking brain I am kinda of assuming that all these issues are related.

So in essence, Sonar is fine at recording its own in house automation, but when relating to NI Kontakt 5 and *some* instruments, it certainly does not. Now, as my DAW I expect it to, and NI, as my instrument handler I expect it to do the bloody same! Otherwise whats the point in composing with these tools?

Again, today, when sound designing I was trying to automate a volume on a track from a Kontakt instrument and no matter what every time I hit space to play it resets everything unless the automation is recorded on Sonar itself rather than the plug in.

Something is getting lost in translation it seems.

I am still trying to play catch up on the situation.  Are the articulations showing up in Event Viewer when you record?
 
 
 
Bob Bone
 

This is something I need to do, record a tester and then inspect EV before saving and restarting to see if something is getting AWOL.

The problem is, as I am sure one can agree, the last thing you wanna do is inspect EV having recorded something and get all BETA... Having said that I shall try this tomorrow with the same Kontakt Instruments and recreate the same vibe, check EV- reload and report back....

But, I strongly suspect EV is a bit if a red herring.

What???!!!???
 
This is preposterous!!!!!
 
Unbelievable!!!!!
 
Unheard of!!!!!!
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Alex has NOT asked if you've reset or rescanned your VSTs
(or has he?).
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Oh how I crack me up.
 

markyzno

CakeAlexS
Ok well that establishes something, I have Komplete and  X3D, I'm not experiencing this with Kontakt but then I'm not running X3D. Maybe X3C users could chirp in.
 
>  But there is nothing in X3D that would address this over X3c *I think*,
 
That really is hard to tell I would say. There were plenty of fixes in X3D that could effect/change Kontakt functionality. So that's my recommendation... until I read this:
 
> No I am not running X3d because of video issues.
 
Then again I get you here, there is that one bug.
 
Cheers...

Alex ....Dude!!!  I dont think its got anything to do with X3c to D etc from what I have read in the documentation.

Naa, the point was there was plenty of code changes around VST's , so you would never know if X3D would fixes this unless you install it (changelogs are just guidelines, code is code). There is a chance it will...
 
However as I said the point is moot as far as you are concerned, you are not installing X3D because of a particular issue, and that's quite understandable... so my advice now is wait for X3E and see what happens (and after installation,  do the thing I'm not allowed to talk about).

Out of curiosity, what is the video issue regarding X3d? There were many posts about video "problems" initially with X3d, but they related to using Microsoft Media Foundation as the default. This document explains how to switch back to DirectShow as the default, which seemed to take care of things.

Anderton
Out of curiosity, what is the video issue regarding X3d? There were many posts about video "problems" initially with X3d, but they related to using Microsoft Media Foundation as the default. This document explains how to switch back to DirectShow as the default, which seemed to take care of things.

That made little difference to me as it goes, its well documented in another thread and X3c is fine for my video work with clients so wont rock the boat on that one till X3e or X4.