cityrat
I don't know... I think touch is an interesting idea, but you have to LOOK at the screen. With 'knobs' etc it's by feel - in the same sense I can't imagine playing 'touch guitar' or 'touch keyboard'.
The greatest part of touch is I touch what I want to automate. The controllers don't always map to what you need at that moment. I think that with ACT the controllers map very fast and about as well as you could hope, but still, you monkey around when you change to a VST or back to the Console or to Track View. When I touch something on the screen I get what I'm after. I'm able to control the variance fairly well. there are times when values flicker high and low or something while I change a parameter, but that's something that happens far less with practice.
For me, I tend to use touch or use the mouse. I don't switch quickly back and forth. I love touch when I am actually playing my guitar or keyboard. Switching from the instrument to the mouse is much clunkier than just touching the screen.
I also like it for adjusting faders. I have used it some on the fly out EQs and it does work, but I am more likely to EQ with the mouse while mixing. I find touch hard on some plugins like the BlueTube plugs. They have buttons too small to use touch with. I repeatedly stab at the buttons with my big fingers and get frustrated.
I'm very fast with a mouse, so it doesn't take much frustration for me to switch to the mouse.
I do a ton of envelope automation, so not being able to work with envelopes is a touch constraint which pushes me to the mouse.
Once I sit back and put my hand on the mouse, it takes a while before I switch back to touch.
************************************
Touch is tons of fun with a friend!
************************************
Read this as you want. :-)
Using touch makes it possible for two people to tweak a mix together in a really fun and cooperative way.