• SONAR
  • I Beg To Dither (p.2)
2013/10/30 06:31:14
Bristol_Jonesey
If you're happy to live with quantization distortion then go ahead and don't use it.
 
As for "using cpu needlessly", this seems to me a very naive appreciation about what dither is all about and also, the amount of cpu overhead used when using any of the popular dithering algorithms is absolutely miniscule.
 
Choosing not to dither when bit reducing is akin to leaving the gray off a microwaved roast dinner in terms of power saving.
Not the best analogy I know, but it doesn't cost you anything to use dither and you run the risk of introducing audible distortion into your otherwise pristine recordings.
2013/10/30 07:28:50
gswitz
I don't think it's like Dolby. Dolby boosted the very high end of the sound above the noise level on the tape and then when you play it back with Dolby On you suppress the same freq range aligning the original signal and suppressing the high end tape noise.
 
The problem with this was that if you played it back with Dolby off (or the wrong dolby) you could just get extra tape hiss.
 
THIS IS NOT THE CASE WITH DITHER.
 
When you Dither appropriately, you get better sound on all playback environments no matter the settings on the device doing the playback. Dither suppresses the noise floor by randomizing it and spreading it over a greater frequency band (like the audible range). DITHER WILL MAKE YOUR RECORDINGS BETTER.
 
Use Dither when changing Bit Depth (like 32 to 24 or 24 to 16). Don't use Dither when going from 88.2 Samples per Sec to 44.1. I have sources that say going from 48 to 44.1 use dither and others that say don't.
 
http://www.amazon.com/Digital-Audio-Explained-For-Engineer/dp/141960001X/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1383132288&sr=8-2&keywords=sweetwater+digital+recording
 
This book says it is appropriate to use dither when changing sample rates where the sample rate is NOT an even division... like 48 to 44.1 but not 88.2 to 44.1.
 
Basically, since it adds the slightest bit of white noise, you want to avoid it where it is not necessary. So, for this reason, I add Dither when going from 32 bit mixdown's to export to 24 bit waves. I usually change sample rate and bit depth at the same time.
2013/10/30 13:51:41
michael diemer
OK, I guess I will use it. Actually, I already have been. I just couldn't decide what setting to use, so I tried to use one in the middle, like power one or two. I guess I'll continue doing that. I only got concerned about CPU because the sonar help files mention it.
2013/10/30 17:25:04
Bristol_Jonesey
Michael, even if it did have cpu implications, it's only for the short amount of time while you're doing your export (or bounce, I suppose) so in the real world, it matters very little
12
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account