michaelhanson
The consistency and the build quality of the instruments that are coming out right now, in my opinion, are incredible. I love my MIM Strat as well, built in the early 90's. I loved the neck so much, I was afraid to purchase and put a new neck on it. I finally bought a new neck 6 months ago, rather than do a refret....its even nicer than the original that was on that Strat.
People have knocked Gibson's for ever. I have owned 3 Les Paul's. The 2013 Les Paul Studio I traded for just recently, is probably the best made Gibson Les Paul that I have owned. Better built by far than the first LP Standard that I bought new in 1982.
Things have changed big time in our lifetime.
When I was starting out nobody I knew ever worked on a guitar. Nobody ever changed anything except the strings.
IMO the internet made a big change for people. The opportunity to get parts, tools, ideas and learn opened the door.
Selection and competition boomed.
Competition now includes independents to these large companies. Everyone is forced into creating a quality product if they want to continue making them.
Quality control and "magic" still allows for products that will satisfy a large percent for those that haven't acquired the experience and knowledge to recognize details and for those that know quality and "magic" when they play it.
Yes the quality and magic can be found in all price ranges and that is why, IMO, people recommend playing it before you buy. Of course one can hassle with returning/exchanging in the search if they choose.
When I read, "American made .....are better than ........made" I think they don't realize how things are or may have had a bad experience and just generalize...which doesn't help them find the truth. (if they're looking for it)