This thread may be old, but to clear up peoples opinons "idk why you would ever use such a travesty, use a real piece of equipment like the rest of us, conform to our money spending ways" mentality, it works just fine for people. Unless you plan on recording Bach or something of that nature, in which you need to record piano strokes all the way up and down the keyboard, using virtual midi software works.
Hell, just to prove a point, I'm using a Windows 10 Tablet-PC, no external sound card/sound processors, no instruments whatsoever. I'm using pure PC power and software, and in the end, it works PERFECTLY.
You don't have to spend money to get something useful, and workable, and whatnot. I'm starting to believe most of these opinions are guys who run music stores where they sell instruments. Selling propaganda that software is ****e, when in fact it's not.
"You should go spend your hard earned bill money on an instrument you may not be able to carry around like this XXXXXX i have in my shop, come buy and pay my bills".
Maybe i'm wrong, or maybe i just can't see eye to eye to a purist, one of those "if it's not held in your hands it's not good" types. ffs if you're so hell bend on recording pure audio, get an old 8-track or cassette tape recorder, and stop bugging with DIGITAL SOFTWARE.
Unless I'm missing the whole point. Either way, I've successfully been using VMPK and MidiYoke for my music needs. Besides mouse clicking, we don't want to stretch out thousands of clicks just to get something worth putting in a song, we want to be able to quickly test these things, progress doesn't have to take 10 hours if you're talented.