eph221
Our music education programs have become so good and ubiquitous that it's just not rare any more to hear great music. Professionals have to rethink the value proposition. :D:D (ducks)
While I do agree that there are some incredibly gifted young people out there, I think a most of those kids are missing the target by a thousand mile. While the mechanical aspect of performance has reached unprecedented level, thanks in large part to all the tools people have at their disposal, a lot of those performers seem to be plagued by an absolute lack of emotion and/or taste.
As it should be - maturing a soul, and the ability to express that soul through music takes time.
This wouldn't be such a source of concern if the public didn't suffer from the exact same problem. Hence, hardly a week goes by w/o some video of a young "prodigy" going viral - and if in certain cases the mechanical aspect of the performance is indeed flawless, it is most often absolutely devoid of soul. The number of child prodigies out there is directly proportional to the number of talentless tone-deaf parents and adults. And they are legions...
From little 8 year old "channeling the soul of Aretha Franklin" to a 12 year old who "gives Yngwie a run for his money" only 3 months after he first picked up the guitar - what always strikes me is that people
really don't hear the difference.
And thanks to TV shows like The Voice, musicians are now expected to provide entertainment to those uneducated, soulless, tone-deaf people, like some kind of feat performing puppy. In fact, the public is so numbed that they must be told that they're about to "feel" something, they need to be walked through the same pattern time after time, and be assured that that the huge epic chorus is just about to explode and that the singer will soon switch to full voice.
Actually, I'm not sure the audience would still know how to react if they didn't have the judges acting as a barometer and the applause signs. I'm not convinced that the formulaic build-up alone would be enough for them to realize that they are feeling something (or should be).