If it is one or two singers, I usually triple each part for normal pop songs and put four voices on a part for a bigger sound.
If it is a larger group (like 6 or 8 singers), two of each is usually good.
Sounds like your were going for a We-Are-The-World thing

which was a combination of lots of voices, a yelly singing style, and room ambience.
I did a weird project that was a musical stage play that told all the major stories of the Bible using new lyrics to 42 classic TV themes. I wrote the lyircs and arranged the music and credited the composers. Paramount would not clear their songs, so all I have is an old VS-1680 demo version that is rough and has zero Melodyne or any other editing. (It's ten years old.) I will share the link later though because there are some fairly good choir sounds considering we did one voice at a time on the 1680 with no way to fix anything.