Things are becoming a little clearer. It is confusing going back in time to figure this stuff out, considering that changes were constantly being made in the process!
To summarize again my situation: I had bought Studio 8.5, but barely used it, upgrading to Producer 8.5 within a few months. I intsalled both Producer patches. But I have had problems with Producer almost from the get go. Deleting a synth would crash it, for example. EWSO basses would crash it. And lately the plugin tool stopped working right. Presciently, a couple years ago I made copies of my install DVD's for 8.5 Producer. There are four of them (Studio 8.5 was a single DVD). Turns out that was a good idea, as when I recently reinstalled Producer (following a total Windows 7 crash), I found that disc one, the main one, wouldn't install. My copy worked fine, however. I also installed Dim Pro and Additional Content from the original discs. I passed on Rapture. I installed both Pro patches.
Producer was working about the same as it had worked originally. I decided to install Studio, hoping it would work right, and give me all the features I need. It does work well, but I'm having trouble with Kontakt. I will install both .2 and .3 updates, hopefully that will solve that problem. If everything works well, it will have been a success. Studio 8.5.3 will then be my latest working version of Sonar, unless other options somehow become available.