• SONAR
  • Been Trying SONAR with a USB 3.0 Flash Drive (p.5)
2017/12/15 01:31:49
gswitz
I want to mention internal ssd works twice as fast at least as through USB 3.
2017/12/15 02:29:23
cparmerlee
gswitz
No, windows will not work on a USB or esata drive for the boot partition. I tried and tried. Linux, however.. .

I have not done it, but this article seems to say it is indeed possible:
https://www.pcmag.com/art...ws-10-from-a-usb-drive
2017/12/16 00:29:46
gswitz
In truth, I tried to do it with Windows 7 and 8 not 10.
 
M$
But that program works only with the Enterprise version of Windows 10 and requires a certified Windows To Go drive. 

 
This isn't a standard USB drive.
 
 https://smile.amazon.com/64GB-DataTraveler-Workspace-Certified-Windows/dp/B00A48LB6K/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1513384256&sr=8-3&keywords=windows+to+go
 
$180 for something you can get for $15 (same size) for Linux.
 
All said, at least it's finally possible for Windows. Now windows junkies can install Linux and when they want Windows boot to a thumb drive.
2017/12/16 01:03:22
cparmerlee
gswitz
M$
But that program works only with the Enterprise version of Windows 10 and requires a certified Windows To Go drive. 


Interesting.  I didn't know about that program.  Here is more detail on it:
https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/deployment/planning/windows-to-go-overview
 
I don't see any indication that Microsoft is imposing a big royalty on it.  It does appear that the drive supplier has to add some firmware features that allow Microsoft to protect their property.  It must not be a very popular feature (Enterprise only) because it was announced 5 years ago, yet there are only a few compatible thumb drives out there.
 
The requirement for the Pro level of OS probably makes this a non-starter.  So I am back to the idea of using Hyper-V as a way to lock up a stable platform for the long term.  I can't find anybody who has actually done this.  The following thread has a bunch of people saying "Ohhh noes, you can't do that", but later in the thread there is a detailed comment from a person who seems to know a lot about Hyper-V.  His assessment is it is possible with caveats.
 
Six years ago, I ran a commercial environment where we had 3 large servers running a dozen virtual machines, and some of those VMs were very performance-critical, real-time systems doing hundreds of transactions per second.  VM technology (both in the software and in the Intel platform support) is really quite impressive and works in many cases that people don't expect it to.
 
2017/12/16 01:19:11
gswitz
https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/previous-versions/windows/it-pro/windows-8.1-and-8/jj592680(v=ws.11)#is-windows-to-go-supported-on-both-usb-20-and-usb-30-drives
 

Is Windows To Go supported on both USB 2.0 and USB 3.0 drives?
No. Windows To Go is supported on USB 3.0 drives that are certified for Windows To Go.

 
Idk if that means it may work but it's your problem if it doesn't. I'm not sure.
 
I just know I've been running Linux on USB for 8 years or so and it works on all kinds of tiny and terrible USB drives. Puppy Linux through Ubuntu Studio.
 
I'm getting tempted to try it.
 
https://www.pcmag.com/art...ws-10-from-a-usb-drive

The first time you use your Windows 10 drive on a different computer, you'll need to establish the necessary Wi-Fi password and other settings. You'll also need to activate Windows 10 each time you use the USB drive on a different PC, so it's best you log in with your Microsoft account, which is linked to your digital license.

2017/12/17 04:35:54
Studioguy1
Gee, I am rather surprised at the negative comments on what is a possibility and certainly a viable thought as things improve.  I have used them for temporary storage of projects for a long time with no problem.  I can easily run between computers and daw formats and it works well.  Of course, I back up everything.  But I see no reason to jump all over a possibility because it may not be my way of doing things.  That's plain crazy.
© 2025 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account