I am investigating a number of DAW options. I'm not ready to disclose my current DAW(s), but I am comparing the Sonar 7 trial with what I already use.
So far, I have spent most of my time testing Sonar 7's audio recording and playback, as well as basic "synth-via-MIDI" recording and playback features. I have done limited VST testing with Absynth and one or two other VSTs, but not enough to form an opinion in that area. I have done no testing with effects yet.
I find Sonar 7 to be on a par with my regular DAW software; neither significantly better nor significantly worse. My other DAW application(s) is/are stable, and Sonar 7 has also been stable. I don't hear any significant differences between audio engines or "quality of sound." All of my DAWs are excellent recording and playback tools.
I find some things to be less intuitive in Sonar. That is minor, because I just look them up. I do find the "online HTML Help" tool to be lacking, because I've only had a 50-50 chance of actually finding the answer to my question. Then I come to this forum and use the search feature. Again, only about a 50-50 chance of getting an answer. Maybe that's because the features have different names in Sonar.
In any event, I look forward to being able to read a more complete "user manual."
I find quite a bit of the Sonar 7 interface somewhat difficult to see and "click" on (see my thread regarding "hard to see" things on the screen). My vision is not really that bad, either. But I am limited to my monitors' native resolution settings. Some things that should be more configurable include (but are not restricted to):
1. Increase size of buttons in track view and console view (I can see MSR and READ/WRITE just fine, but sometimes their hotspots are hard targets to find).
2. Allow me to make huge, fat meters in console view, and somewhat fatter meters than provided for in track view. This would help me get visual confirmation of signal when I'm sitting 10 feet away at my keyboards or in front of my music stand with an open mic in front of me and a cumbersome-to-walk-with instrument in hand.
3. Allow me to clean up the "inspector" portion of track view. Maybe have a "verbose/brief" option that I could switch on/off for each track or for the project globally (similar to MSR)
On the plus side, I like being able to configure with icons and track colors. For some people, that's a "toy" feature, but not for me. I'm very visual and I organize my thoughts better when things line up correctly, have a certain appearance, consistency, and/or a good graphic to set them aside from the rest of the visual "noise" on the screen.
I would like to see Track and Console icon selection become faster and less "fiddly." Right click, scroll, click on my selection, for example.
I also like being able to use high-contrast track color selections for ease of sight, especially when looking at MIDI tracks while seated at my keyboards across the room.
The step designer and drum functionality is interesting, and I look forward to learning those features. But until I actually get to using them, I don't see that they're vastly better than my other DAW software. We'll see, I may change my mind on that.
At this time, I have decided to purchase the U250 package. It comes with Sonar 7 Studio Edition. I chose this because the USB interface will fill a niche for me. It will work on a workstation or a laptop; The interface is bus-powered, so that will make for a good solution for mobile work if I choose to do that in a couple years. But that interface will also work with my old DAW application, so I am not being "forced' to change my DAW.
And that brings me to my point. I'm really in the best of situations here. I am actually choosing to
add Sonar to my rig, not to replace something else with it. It's not my intention to "switch over."
Like any good woodcraftsman, I will have more than one tool in my toolbox, and (hopefully) I will gain enough expertise to be able to use each tool for whatever purposes that tool is best suited for. I look forward to learning more about Sonar and figuring out its best uses for me.