I started with Music Creator 2002 (a Cakewalk product) in 2003 and bought Dimension Pro later on. I then bought Sonar 6 Producer a couple of years ago. Almost all of my work is software synth and I really got Music Creator only because it was bundled with Edirol Orchestral-HQ (an absolutely wonderful product, the likes of which has never been duplicated to my knowledge). Just last month, Cakewalk offered an upgrade deal on Sonar 8.5 Producer so I bought it for my new AMD Windows 7-64 computer that I use mostly for CGI. But after all the work I did with Music Creator with mostly the Edirol Orchestral-HQ (love the product!) I was disappointed that Edirol discontinued it and I may never get a 64-bit version because it is no longer produced. Because my work uses Orchestral HQ so heavily, I doubt that I will be using Sonar 8.5 any time soon appreciably because Cakewalk doesn't make any software synths that come even close the the quality and usability of the Edirol Orch-HQ product. I have spent some time with Dimension Pro but I find it to only be a specialty synth that is only used now and then for a special purpose because it is more trouble to use (as with all of the other Cakewalk synths I have). Cakewalk synths were designed for hardware sound guys used to hardware sound boxes and were not designed for modern computer people who don't come with the background and baggage that dedicated hardware box people have. So the Edirol Orchestral HQ was and will continue to be my workhorse when it comes to rendering my compositions into audible sound. Let me add that I do not have, and probably will never have, any MIDI hardware. I am a computer guy and the keyboard I use says QWERTY on the keys. I score most all my music and only add sound effects where needed so audio tracks only rarely get used in my music. Where I do use audio tracks is for recording narrations that I use to produce industrial training videos.
Let me say that, even though most of the sounds that come out of the VSC that comes with Sonar sound cheap and cheasy, it does have a few good ones like the steel drums, and the pan pipe and a few others. But the strings are horrible and that is where GPO could be used. However, Edirol Orchestral HQ is much easier to use and accounts for up 90% of my orchestration. My only complaints with that product are: 1) EO-HQ is limited to 16 channels (Dimension Pro is limited to 4 but you can instantiate another one-a minor pain), 2) EO-HQ requires me to put the disk back in every couple of weeks, and most of all 3) EO-HQ was not ported to Windows 7 and has been discontinued. Looks like my old XP system with only a P4 will become my dedicated DAW and my new system will likely only be used for computer modelling/animation and video editing (visual stuff). Too bad. I was hoping to do some surround sound. But without Edirol Orchestral-HQ, what's the point?
SO CAKEWALK MARKETING, IF YOU ARE READING THIS: PLEASE BRING BACK Edirol Orchestral-HQ! I don't care what you want to call it. It is better than any of the synths you have (by far)!