• Songs
  • Phil and Friends present- Homeland (Re-Imagined) (p.2)
2015/03/27 20:57:00
Rimshot
Super good job to all.  Love the song. I believe in the words 100%. A great message. 
The playing is really good.  Danny did a spot on job on the mix. Sonically, this really shows off the frequency range - good lows, mids, and highs that are well balanced. 
 
Great collab.
2015/03/28 15:03:25
philz
chasmcg
Nicely done. Enjoyed this a lot.


Thank you, Chas!
2015/03/28 16:03:49
SongCraft
Outstanding song, performances and production. Top-Notch
 
Minor Critiques: Vocal artifacts (higher harmony) lets it down, would sound much better done by male with excellent falsetto or female vocalist, or both.
2015/03/29 03:03:44
evadianepug
What a relevant song.  Well played and produced.
2015/03/29 16:04:36
philz
daryl1968
Great job on the final mix and production. Thanks for asking me to be part of it :)



Thanks, Daryl, and thank you for your work on the tune.
2015/03/29 16:06:29
philz
tbosco
Nice solid tones in this one!  Would love to hear that snare a little hotter to "drive" the tune....make it rock.  Are the vocals a little buried around the 2:40 mark?  Maybe a little louder would drive the tune home for the ending.  Just my humble opinion here.
 
Nice collab!!!


Thanks, Tony, and thank you for the helpful crits.
2015/03/29 16:31:44
teego
You all did a great job on this. I thought the guitars were a little hot in the beginning as someone else mentioned but that is just personal preference. I really like the song and production.
2015/03/30 09:22:14
Starise
Love this and the message hits home. I'm getting the drums a little harsh in my cans, but I'm using a buds cans and I don't trust em'....nice song guys! I'll try and listen on my better setup later on. I like the arangement a lot...all did a wonderful job on it.
2015/03/30 20:06:24
MarkusClinus
Phil - nice job - to all. I really enjoyed this - great singing - great playing.
2015/04/03 19:13:53
philz
jamesyoyo
Agree with Tony on the snare. There are a lot of good tones in this. Guitars sound just a touch hot here.
The drums sound great and are really played well.


Hi James.  Thanks for the pointers and the listen.
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account