Not all audio programs runs well or at all under xp compatibility on win7 so only time will tell ... have you tried to run Sonar in compatibility mode?
I agree, nor Reaper or Studio One Artist can serve as a replacement for Sonar power users.
I think Sonar is a bit different DAW than the rest and hard to replace especially for the old longtime Cakewalk/Sonar users ...
I will keep my Sonar machine running for many years (my first DAW from 1995 is still alive and well: Win 95, Cubase Audio XT with Digidesign Session 8 hardware

) but I also already run other DAW's, Samplitude, Reaper, Harrison Mixbus ...
Reaper is very efficient if you only use 3d party VST's & VSTi's as i doesn't comes bundled with anything, but their few own plugins are excellent but as said no replacement without adding 3d party stuff ...
I think the top versions of Cubase or Samplitude is the best replacement for Sonar Platinum feature wise.
Depending on your needs, Cubase coming with their midi heritage to meet up your Sonar midi standard. Samplitude coming first as audio only, midi added later which are great now have great mastering tools, Cd burning ...
I got Sonar and Samplitude at the same time coming from Cubase, I now mostly use Samplitude as my main DAW as it sounds excellent and suits my workflow best, but I really like Sonar, sound just as excellent, great tools, really wanted to get into the Sonar mindset ... Sonar coexist with Samplitude on my DAW and i use several Sonar VST/VSTi's in Samplitude, like the vocal Strip, Percussion Strip, the SI-instruments (Samplitude got very similar ones, just as good but not sounding exactly the same, great to stack together with the Samplitude one's to get a fat more organic sound)
/Thomas