• SONAR
  • Take lanes and comping with multi-miced instruments
2013/07/26 11:22:28
neirbod
I am trying to figure out how to work with take lanes, in particular how to comp drums and other instruments that have multiple mics.  I understand how to comp on something like a vocal track where there are typically breaks so you can mute and solo various parts of a take segment by segment.  But for drums (for example) I will sometimes want to patch in a section from another take and then nudge the clips and use fades to blend them given there typically is not a clean break anywher to employ the mute tool.  This was quite easy in 8.5.3 using layers, but I can't seem to make it work in X2a using take lanes.  I can't figure out how to select the same takes from different elements (e.g., kick and snare), cut out the pieces I want and move them around. I can get to the point of selecting the correct clips, but as soon as I try to then select the appropriate time range to cut or move Sonar deselects all but one clip.  .  I am hoping I am missing something and that this is indeed possible and easy.
 
Thanks
2013/07/26 11:26:31
gswitz
I use track templates that allow me to mute and solo takes as folders.
2013/07/26 11:31:58
brconflict
What I do is use Gain Automation for the cross-fading. Keep the Gain at Unity (0db) until that lane needs to drop out. Create the Gain Automation points so that your Unity gain on a specific Lane goes to -INF (manual muting without using the Mute button) in a slanted curve, bring up another Lane that you want at the same, but inverse slant also using Gain Automation. This can be a little time-consuming, but the results can be near 100.00% accurate. I recommend not to go over unity (0db) gain, however, especially if you use a compressor on the channel, as this will affect your sound on that Track.
2013/07/26 12:42:26
Studious
You should be able to do everything with take lanes that you did with layers.  The only difference is you will encounter more bugs with take lanes*.
 
One thing to definitely use on multi-mic tracks:  Clip Groups!  In Preferences, Sonar can be set to automatically group clips across tracks recorded in the same take.  Or after the fact, select multiple clips, right-click and "create selection group" (it no longer says "clip group" despite the X2 documentation).  Once grouped, selecting a clip selects all clips in its group, and you can edit as a group.
 
It would be great if we could freely edit a group without having to explicitly select a clip first.  So many times I think the group is selected, yet I'm only editing a single clip (then must undo everything and re-do as the group).  Anyways, be sure to always select a clip before trying to edit its group.
 
* Some issues with take lanes:
- Moving clips between lanes or tracks is like Plinko: you don't know where it's gonna end up until you let it go.
- Clip automation becomes unselectable.  You may have to collapse all lanes and re-expand to select a clip envelope.
- Unexpected things occur sometimes when you delete a lane.  Sometimes it deletes clips from other lanes!
- Can't recall off-hand what other take lane bugs are out there, but be careful to verify before locking in edits.
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account