Can anyone explain to me the rationale behind adding a single envelope node to every track envelope every time the Split Tool is used?
 
This is a major annoyance in my workflow and in my opinion should be an option. The only way I could see this behaviour being useful is if the Cut Tool inserted two nodes instead of one.
 
I am constantly repairing my envelopes after being mutilated by the Cut Tool!
 
-mal

What version of Sonar?

Currently using Producer X2 but this has been the behavior ever since I started using Sonar Home Edition (3 or 4).

I must confess I would never split a clip after I used automation.

Just because it isn't in your workflow doesn't mean it isn't a valid one. I do mostly live recordings and minor edits after application of envelopes is par for the course for me.
 
This is irrelevant to the question though - why change the envelope when splitting clips. This also includes moving selections where implicit cuts are done.
 
This behavior is just silly.

Without trying to sound obtuse, what difference does it make?

Bristol_Jonesey
Without trying to sound obtuse, what difference does it make?

with out trying to sound like a knob, I had to go look up "obtuse"
cool word bj

Beyond the fact that it looks messy to my slightly OCD mind, it breaks the envelope. If I want to change my envelope I change it. If I am cutting a clip then it should have no effect whatsoever to *track* envelopes.
 
Am I making sense? All the current functionality does is force me to remove the auto-added nodes. Track envelopes are track attributes, not clip attributes. 

sea_ferring
Just because it isn't in your workflow doesn't mean it isn't a valid one. I do mostly live recordings and minor edits after application of envelopes is par for the course for me.
 
This is irrelevant to the question though - why change the envelope when splitting clips. This also includes moving selections where implicit cuts are done.
 
This behavior is just silly.

That was not the point of my post. I was trying to convey the fact that I would never see this "problem". But now that you bring it up why not change your work flow?

If it made sense to change my workflow then perhaps I would, but an advanced tool like Sonar should not dictate workflow.
 
My point as made above is that modifying *track* envelopes on an action that is in clip scope does not make sense.